Jeff Chiu/APGiants left-hander Madison Bumgarner is a big reason the Giants have the best record in baseball.

Giants, A's take opposite approaches

The A's are headed to the playoffs and the Giants to baseball oblivion, and a big reason is their approach to hitting. The A's have a plan, while the Giants just hack away.

A hitting coach can only do so much. It is much easier for a pitching coach to impact the game because each play starts with the pitcher. If his approach is improved, he can make a big jump. The hitter must always adjust to the pitcher, which is much more difficult.

Still, the right hitting coach can make a difference. Chili Davis is doing that for the A's. Before every at-bat, he makes certain that a hitter has a specific plan once he's in the batter's box.

The A's are often free swingers. Brandon Moss has struck out more than any Giants hitters — but he's also hit 16 home runs, as has Josh Donaldson. Yoenis Cespedes, though he's not hitting for average, has 15. Hunter Pence with 14 and Buster Posey with 13 are the Giants' leaders.

The A's also work the pitch count, which is important in this era because managers don't usually let starters go much beyond 100 pitches.

The last game the A's played before the break, against the Boston Red Sox on Sunday at the Coliseum, was typical of their approach. For six innings, they didn't get a hit. In the seventh, Coco Crisp got an infield single and Donaldson absolutely crushed a fastball to tie the game, which they won on a Donaldson single in the 11th.

By contrast, the Giants just keep hacking away. Their only smart hitters are Marco Scutaro, who learned his style long before he came to the Giants, and Posey, who was a polished hitter when he was in college.

Overall, their plate discipline is terrible. For the season, they have almost 100 fewer walks than the A's. Some hitters are good bad-ball hitters, and Pablo Sandoval is a classic example. I certainly wouldn't change his style because it works for him, at least until he eats himself out of a career.

Other Giants need help, though, and I see no evidence that hitting coach Hensley Meulens is supplying it. There are two specific examples: Pence and Brandon Belt.

Pence is simply trying too hard to bring the Giants out of a season-long hitting slump by himself. He is overswinging constantly, without any plate discipline and just driving himself deeper into a slump. I admire his attitude but he needs advice from a coach to cool it.

Belt has struck out more than any other Giant because he has a specific problem. Up to the time he has two strikes, Belt has excellent plate discipline. But when he has two strikes, he will chase the high inside fastball. Knowing that, pitchers give him a steady diet of that pitch when he reaches two strikes, knowing he couldn't do anything with that pitch even if he hits it. With all the video available now, Meulens should be showing that to Belt repeatedly to get him to change his pattern.

Apparently, that's not happening, so Belt, Pence and most of their teammates will keep hacking away into oblivion.

Glenn Dickey has been covering Bay Area sports since 1963 and also writes on Email him at

A'sGiantsGlenn DickeySan Francisco Giants

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at

Just Posted

Diners sit outside Caffe Greco in North Beach on Monday, June 15, 2020. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
SF becomes first Bay Area County to move to least restrictive COVID-19 category

Change to ‘yellow’ will allow more indoor dining and fitness, reopening non-essential offices

Police release an image a cracked windshield on a Prius that Cesar Vargas allegedly tried to carjack. Vargas, who was shot by police a short time later, can be seen in videos jumping on the windshield and pushing a Muni passenger who disembarked from a bus. (Courtesy SFPD
SFPD releases videos of deadly police shooting

Cesar Vargas killed after reports of carjacking with knife

Organizers of the San Francisco International Arts Festival had planned to use parts of Fort Mason including the Parade Ground, Eucalyptus Grove and Black Point Battery to host performances by about a dozen Bay Area arts groups. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Arts festival sues city over permit denial

Organizer says outdoor performances should be treated like demonstrations, religious gatherings

New legislation would make sure supportive housing tenants don’t pay more than 30 percent of their income for rent.. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner))
Supportive housing tenants could get more help paying the rent

Supportive housing tenants struggling to pay rent could soon see their payments… Continue reading

An oversight body for San Francisco’s mental health programs may be restructured after questions were raised about its management and lack of effectiveness. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Behavioral health oversight body looks for new start — and staff — after mismanagement

Members of an oversight body for San Francisco’s behavioral health programs said… Continue reading

Most Read