Frantz: The problem's not McNabb’s skin color

It was in 2003 when Rush Limbaugh was fired by ESPN for his ridiculous and incorrect assessment of the media’s coverage of Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb.

“I don’t think he’s been that good from the get-go,” Limbaugh said at the time. “The media has been very desirous that a black quarterback do well … McNabb got a lot of the credit for the performance of the team that he really didn’t deserve.”

Limbaugh was wrong on so many levels that it’s hard to describe in this short space, but it matters not. His willingness to put his low “football IQ” on display is not the issue here. Donovan McNabb’s classy response to Rush’s commentary, however, is.

“It’s sad that you’ve got to go to skin color,” the QB said. “I thought we were through that whole deal.”


As a huge McNabb fan, I was impressed — but not surprised — to hear his thoughtful, delicate reply. Not wanting to blow the story out of proportion, he declined an opportunity to fire back, choosing to let his play do his talking for him. Now, four years later, the question has to be, “What changed?” If McNabb thought that skin color should no longer be an issue when evaluating quarterbacks in 2003, why has he suddenly placed it on the table in 2007?

McNabb told HBO last week that black quarterbacks are judged more harshly than white quarterbacks.

“There’s not that many

African-American quarterbacks, so we have to do a little bit extra,” he said. White quarterbacks, he claimed, “don’ t get criticized as much as we do. They don’t.”

The reason McNabb’s words have caused such a stir across the NFL is that the days when black players were thought by certain bigoted team executives to be too intellectually “inferior” to play the QB position are supposed to have been long gone. Pioneers such as Doug Williams, who became the first black QB to win a Super Bowl, set the stage for future Hall of Famers such as Warren Moon, along with superstars such as Randall Cunningham who redefined the position.

In today’s NFL, did anyone even mention the skin color of JaMarcus Russell when the Raiders made him the top overall pick in the draft? Or Vince Young last year? Michael Vick with the Atlanta Falcons? Or McNabb himself when he joined Daunte Culpepper and Akili Smith as first-round QBs taken in 1999?

The notion that black QBs can’t handle the position was dispelled years ago, and to use it as a means of deflecting criticism today is to grasp at straws.

“I pass for 300 yards,” McNabb told HBO, “and our team wins by seven, [and people say] ‘Ah, he could’ve made this throw, they would have scored if he did this.’”

Really? Kind of like a quarterback going to the Super Bowl, and despite every victory in the regular season and through the playoffs, the fans and media bludgeoned him with, “They won in spite of him, not because of him!”

Rex Grossman, of course, is white.

Black QBs face harsher criticism than white QBs, Donovan? Please, allow me to introduce you to Joey Harrington. Or Tim Couch. Or David Carr. Or Ryan Leaf.

The truth is that QBs who play lousy games are QBs who hear the loudest complaints. Complete passes and win games, you’ll be cheered from on high. Throw picks and lose games, even your friends drop you from their Christmas card lists. That’s the nature of the beast.

Donovan McNabb has been an outstanding quarterback in the NFL, and an even better person. But it’s not the color of his skin that seems to be the problem. It’s the thickness of it.

Sports personality Bob Frantz is a regular contributor to The Examiner. E-mail him at

Other Sportssports

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at

Just Posted

Muni’s K-Ingleside line will return six months earlier than previously announced. <ins>(Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)</ins>
K-Ingleside train to return on May 15

Announcement comes on the heels of pressure from Supervisor Myrna Melgar

Former Stockton Mayor Michael Tubbs spoke to San Francisco’s new Guaranteed Income Advisory Group on April 16. (Courtesy SFGOV)
City launches task force to explore Universal Basic Income programs

San Francisco on Friday launched a guaranteed income task force that could… Continue reading

Demonstrators march from Mission High School towards the San Francisco Police station on Valencia Street. (Jordi Molina/ Special to the S.F. Examiner)
Vigil, march honors those killed by police

Deaths of Daunte Wright, Roger Allen and others prompt renewed calls for defunding

A Recology employee stands at the comapany’s recycling facility on Pier 96 in 2016. (Jessica Christian/2016 S.F. Examiner)
Nuru scandal: Feds charge second former Recology executive with bribery

A second former Recology executive is facing charges for allegedly bribing ex-Public… Continue reading

Kiana Williams
Stanford’s Kiana Williams drafted by WNBA champion Seattle Storm

Kiana Williams is going from one championship team to another. A senior… Continue reading

Most Read