Dickey: Rodgers-Smith debate resurfaces

Mike Nolan’s worst nightmare is looming. Though the 49ers-Green Bay Packers game at Candlestick is only an exhibition, if Aaron Rodgers has a good game, it will remind people how Nolan blew his first and most important decision with the 49ers.

To review: In early 2005, though he had never been an NFL head coach, Nolan was named coach and general manager by 49ers owner John York. The Niners had the first pick in the draft and chose Alex Smith over Rodgers.

NFL insiders think Nolan thought he could trade Smith to Tampa Bay for an extra draft choice and pick up Rodgers, a former Cal star, with the Buccaneers’ pick, No. 5 in the first round. That fits with everything I’ve observed about Nolan. He’s so arrogant, he always thinks he knows more than anybody else, though there is no evidence to support that conclusion.

His drafting of Smith wasn’t as big a mistake as his handling of him. Smith’s first season was a disaster. He was trying to adjust to a pro-style offense after operating out of a spread offense for his only two seasons of major college ball, he had below-average receivers and no pass protection.

In his second year, Norv Turner was the offensive coordinator and Smith made big strides, but then last year, when Turner left, Jim Hostler took over and the offensive game plans were terrible (I suspect Nolan was more involved than he should have been). Smith was injured early, but instead of protecting his quarterback, Nolan insisted his shoulder injury wasn’t affecting his play. Smith tried to play until he finally told the media that he could no longer play and needed surgery, which ended his season.

Why is Nolan still the coach? Possibly because York didn’t want to pay off the final two years of his contract, but I think a more likely explanation is that York, having been so thoroughly flummoxed by Nolan in his interview, didn’t want to face another coaching search.

One positive came out of the rubble, though: York elevated Scot McCloughan to general manager. It is now McCloughan who’s in charge and he won’t hesitate to fire Nolan if the 49ers don’t show a marked improvement this fall. McCloughan would conduct the coaching interviews, and he won’t be so easily fooled.

Though the assumption is that new offensive coordinator Mike Martz, who has been a head coach, would be elevated, that’s not a certainty. McCloughan has many contacts in the league because of his background — his father, Kent, played for the Raiders and is now their scouting director, and his older brother, David, is working in the 49ers’ scouting department. He might have another choice.

Martz has said that Smith has the best physical skills of his three quarterbacks, but Smith’s confidence has taken a big hit because of the way Nolan has handled him, and he took another hit when Nolan announced there would be open competition for the starting job this summer.

The only way Nolan can come out of this mess looking good is if Smith wins the starting competition and has an outstanding year.

At the moment, though, it appears J.T. O’Sullivan has the inside track to start. If he wins the job and Rodgers has a good game Saturday night, it won’t be long before Nolan’s job title is preceded by ex.

Glenn Dickey has been covering Bay Area sports since 1963 and also writes on www.GlennDickey.com. E-mail him at glenndickey@hotmail.com.

Glenn Dickeysports

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

Giants second baseman Donovan Solano scores on a double in the seventh inning against the Dodgers at Oracle Park on July 29. (Chris Victorio/Special to The Examiner)
Will the Giants make the playoffs? Kris Bryant may be the answer

By Chris Haft Special to The Examiner You’d be hard-pressed to find… Continue reading

Tiffany Carter, a co-founder of SF Black Wallstreet, at her restaurant, Boug Cali West Coast Creole Shack in the La Cocina Marketplace on Friday, July 30, 2021. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
SF Black Wallstreet: Helping residents build wealth, reclaim spaces they’ve had to leave

Tiffany Carter moved back to her hometown of San Francisco five years… Continue reading

A prescribed fire at Sequoia and Kings Canyon National Parks was conducted in June 2016 to reduce hazardous fuel loading, increase watershed health, and restore the natural fire cycle in the Redwood Canyon area ecosystem. (Photo courtesy Rebecca Paterson/National Park Service)
Experts, UC scientists discuss wildfires in the state’s riskiest regions

Wildfires are nothing new in California’s history, but the magnitude and frequencies… Continue reading

Fourth-grade students at Lucerne Valley Elementary School don masks and Western wear for a “Walk Through California” history day during in-person instruction. (Courtesy of Krystal Nelson)
Confusion over mask mandate for California schools sparks tension between districts and parents

By Diana Lambert EdSource Shifting rules around mask mandates at schools are… Continue reading

Steven Buss, left, and Sachin Agarwal, co-founders of Grow SF, a new group that aims to offer folks a moderate take on SF politics, on Friday, July 30, 2021. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
Grow SF: New tech group aims to promote moderate ideals to political newcomers

Sachin Agarwal has lived in San Francisco for 15 years. But the… Continue reading

Most Read