Dickey: Hill’s play holding 49ers back

The Atlanta Falcons exposed the 49ers in their 45-10 thrashing on Sunday: The Niners have no offense, largely because Shaun Hill is a below average NFL quarterback.

The 49ers had started 3-1 because of a strong defense that held their first four opponents to 53 points. But even then, there were signs of a coming breakdown because the offense scored only two touchdowns in each of those games.

The most telling sign came against the St. Louis Rams, the NFL’s weakest team east of Oakland. Hill struggled for most of the game as the offense scored only one touchdown against the woeful Rams in the first three quarters. The defense scored two touchdowns and special teams added another for a 35-0 win that sent 49ers fans home happy.

Until the next Sunday.

Hill started out poorly, with a tipped pass that was turned into an interception, and he completely lost his composure. Opposing teams have learned that if they put pressure on him, Hill doesn’t know how to deal with it. TV broadcasters noted that in the 49ers opener against Arizona. He ran four times for 53 yards against the Falcons, but otherwise just threw inaccurately or went down on a sack.

His one successful deep throw in five games was a 51-yard completion to Isaac Bruce against the Cardinals, when no pass rusher was in the same zip code with him and Bruce had two steps on his defender. That combination won’t happen often. When he was under pressure later in that game on a similar play, his pass wasn’t close to Bruce. When deep throws were called against the Falcons, he wasn’t close to hitting a receiver.

Some readers have compared Hill to Joe Montana, who didn’t have the strongest arm ever, but the comparison is ludicrous. Montana had some spectacular games as a collegian, most notably his comeback win in the Cotton Bowl. Hill’s collegiate career was so undistinguished, he wasn’t even drafted. Montana as a pro had great vision of the whole field, which Hill does not. Montana excelled at hitting a receiver in stride, so he could run for more yardage; even on short passes. Hill’s receivers often have to stop and wait for the pass to get to them.

A much better comparison for Hill is with the inadequate quarterbacks between John Brodie and Montana. Remember Scott Bull, Joe Reed, Norman Snead? Of course, the 49ers were losers with all of them.

To compensate for Hill’s deficiencies, coach Mike Singletary and offensive coordinator Jimmy Raye have put together game plans which emphasized running. They work better with Frank Gore in there, and Gore will be back after this week’s bye. But NFL teams rarely get to the playoffs without better quarterbacks than Hill.

It wouldn’t surprise me to see Alex Smith as the starter at some point this season. Smith has much more physical ability than Hill, and the 49ers could open up their offense with him.

Next year, rookie Nate Davis may be in the mix; he has a strong, accurate arm and good football sense. The 49ers might also try to draft a quarterback or trade for one in the offseason.

One thing is certain: They won’t be legitimate playoff contenders until they have improved quarterbacking. Right now, they’re like a man trying to win a race on one leg.

Glenn Dickey has been covering Bay Area sports since 1963 and also writes on www.GlennDickey.com. E-mail him at glenndickey@hotmail.com.

49ersGlenn DickeyNinerssports

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

U.S. Attorney David Anderson announces federal firearms charges against two men for their roles in a March 2019 shooting outside the Fillmore Heritage Center in a news conference alongside SFPD staff at the Phillip Burton Federal Building on Thursday, Jan. 9, 2020. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Departing U.S. attorney predicts corruption probe will continue

David Anderson shook up City Hall as top federal prosecutor

Board of Supervisors President Shamann Walton, a former school board member, has been asked to help secure an agreement between the school district and teacher’s union. <ins>(Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)</ins>
 <ins></ins>
Supervisor Walton tapped to mediate teacher contract talks

District and union at odds over hours in-person students should be in the classroom

California is set to receive supplies of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine, which is still under review by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. (Courtesy photo)
California could receive 380K doses of new J&J COVID vaccine next week

California could receive 380,300 doses of the new Johnson & Johnson vaccine… Continue reading

Disability advocates protested outside the home of San Francisco Health Officer Tomas Aragon. (Courtesy Brooke Anderson)
Vaccine rollout plan for people with disabilities remains deeply flawed

On February 13, disability activists paid a visit to the house of… Continue reading

A Bay Area Concrete Recycling facility that opened on PG&E property in 2019. Former PG&E employees have been accused of accepting bribes from Bay Area Concrete. (Courtesy of Bay Area Concrete Recycling via ProPublica)
Lawsuit reveals new allegations against PG&E contractor accused of fraud

By Scott Morris Bay City News Foundation Utility giant Pacific Gas &… Continue reading

Most Read