Dickey: Giants doomed without a farm system

A local columnist has produced a novel theory for the Giants’ demise: Brian Sabean’s brain turned to mush when the Giants adopted a plan of building around Barry Bonds.

So, we really shouldn’t blame Sabean for trading Joe Nathan, Francisco Liriano and Boof Bonser for one (bad) year of A. J. Pierzynski, or for trading Jeremy Accardo for half a year of Shea Hillenbrand, or for signing Edgardo Alfonzo and Ray Durham (twice!) to too lucrative free-agent deals, or for throwing a ridiculous amount of money at Barry Zito while underbidding for the slugger the Giants needed, or for signing over-the hill veterans such as Rich Aurilia and Ryan Klesko.

The devil made him do it.

The Giants’ slide parallels the slide made by the 49ers in the late ’90s after they had decided to bring in free agents to surround Steve Young in a futile attempt to get to a sixth Super Bowl.

But nobody blamed the 49ers’ plan for their failures. Fans and media alike realized that, no matter what your plan, you need to make good decisions.

The 49ers’ failure was due to bad decisions on free agents and in the draft — Jim Druckenmiller? — not the plan.

And the Giants’ failure is due to similar bad decisions. Giants’ owner Peter Magowan has some culpability in this because he has to sign off on decisions, but it is Sabean who is chiefly responsible.

In retrospect, the turning point was probablythe Giants’ failure to pursue Vladimir Guerrero as a free agent before the 2004 season. That was foreshadowed when Sabean traded Mattt Williams in 1997, saying he didn’t want too much of the payroll devoted to two players. That decision was a good one. Passing on Guerrero was not.

Had the Giants signed Guerrero, who hit 104 home runs in his first three full seasons with the Angels, they would have had a combination comparable to the Boson Red Sox grouping of David Ortiz and Manny Ramirez for two of the last three seasons. This year, they would not have been forced into the desperation re-signing of Bonds.

But even before that, the Giants’ failure to develop position players while Sabean has been in charge, first as player personnel director and then as general manager, has doomed them.

Many fans were enraged when the Giants promised to go younger for this season and then fielded a team that was slightly older than in 2006.

But, the only way a team can get significantly younger is by bringing in players from its farm system, and the Giants are bereft of good prospects.

The contrast was stark as the A’s swept the Giants in three games over the weekend.

This year, the A’s brought up Travis Buck, who looks as if he’ll be a strong Rookie of the Year candidate, to go with other farm system products such as Nick Swisher, Eric Chavez, Bobby Crosby and Dan Johnson. Kurt Suzuki has been brought up to back up Jason Kendall, with the expectation that he’ll start next season.

The Giants’ only regular from their farm system is Pedro Feliz. Because of injuries, Kevin Frandsen and Dan Ortmeier started on Sunday, but Frandsen has the look of a career backup and Ortmeier doesn’t belong on a major-league roster.

That’s Sabean’s legacy, but don’t blame him.

The devil made him do it.

Glenn Dickey has been covering Bay Area sportssince 1963 and also writes on www.GlennDickey.com. E-mail him at glenndickey@hotmail.com.

Glenn Dickeysports

Just Posted

San Francisco health experts recommend that pregnant women should receive the COVID-19 vaccine, as well as a booster shot. (Unai Huizi/Shutterstock)
What pregnant women need to know about COVID and booster shots

Questions regarding COVID-19 booster shots for pregnant people have been pouring in… Continue reading

Examiner reporter Ben Schneider drives an Arcimoto Fun Utility Vehicle along Beach Street in Fisherman’s Wharf on Tuesday, Oct. 19, 2021. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
Could San Francisco’s tiny tourist cruisers become the cars of the future?

‘Fun Utility Vehicles’ have arrived in The City

Badly needed rain cooled off pedestrians on Market Street in The City on Wednesday. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
Storm door opens in San Francisco — what will the rains bring?

‘Come Monday, fire season in Northern California should be done’

The so-called “twindemic” that public health officials in California and elsewhere warned about last year — the combined threat of influenza and COVID-19 — was largely eased by the wide use of face masks, physical distancing and reduced travel, experts say. But their concerns are back this year. (Shutterstock)
COVID and the flu: Is a ‘twindemic’ threat lurking again?

‘Because of so little disease last year, population immunity is likely lower’

49ers' quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo hopes to return to the field this weekend to lead San Francisco against the Colts. (Photo courtesy of 49ers)
NFL Week 7 picks: Niners face crucial matchup against the Colts

San Francisco could join Seattle on the brink of irrelevancy in the NFC West with another loss

Most Read