carry edmondson/usa today sportsMichael Crabtree caught two passes for 68 yards in his season debut Sunday.

carry edmondson/usa today sportsMichael Crabtree caught two passes for 68 yards in his season debut Sunday.

A “Challenge” replay system not right for baseball

It's Aug. 18, 2014. The Giants are recharged and the Los Angeles Dodgers are in town for a three-game set with first place in the National League West on the line.

The score is tied 3-3 with no outs in the bottom of the ninth when Angel Pagan hits a slow roller to third base and beats the throw by half-a-step. Or did he?

Manager Don Mattingly throws the challenge flag and the game is stopped. You glance up at the clock in center field and notice it's already 10:30 p.m. You need to be up for work in less than eight hours.

The game is delayed for several minutes before review officials in New York rule that there isn’t enough video evidence to overturn the call. Then, Marco Scutaro steps into the batter’s box and strikes out after fouling off six straight fastballs in a lengthy 12-pitch at-bat. It’s 10:50 p.m.

Brandon Belt is up next, which sends Mattingly to the bullpen for a lefty, leading to another break in the action. It's almost 11 p.m. by the time Pagan gets caught stealing second on a 2-2 pitch. The play is close, but Pagan looks like he's out from the dugout.

Nevertheless, Bruce Bochy asks the umpires to give it another look because he has two challenges in his pocket. It will give Belt a minute to cool down and forget about that questionable strike-two call on the outside of the plate.

The action resumes after a few more minutes. Pagan is ruled out, as expected, but the challenge pays off when a refocused Belt extends the inning by drawing a walk.

At this point, Mattingly goes back to the bullpen to get a right-hander to face Buster Posey and it's 11:15 p.m. before the former-MVP steps into the batter's box.

Despite the pitching change, Posey slaps a single to right. You're thrilled that you stuck around until you see Mattingly signal for another left-hander to face Roger Kieschnick, who's pinch hitting for a slumping Hunter Pence.

At 11:30 p.m., Kieschnick loads up the bases by nubbing out an infield single. It's another bang-bang play that Mattingly challenges to give his right-handers more time to warm up in the bullpen. In doing so, he also settles down the crowd by the time Joaquin Arias steps in to bat more than an hour after Pagan led off the inning.

This story gets a happy ending, though. Arias scores Belt with an unambiguous single up the middle and you get to see the nine-inning game reach its conclusion before midnight.

This example might be extreme, but it shows why Major League Baseball can't go to a “challenge” system when it institutes video replay next season. The proposed plan will make a slow game even slower and lead to abuses by managers looking for strategic edges.

The point of replay is to reverse the most egregious calls to ensure the game is decided on the field. This can be done efficiently by putting an eye in the sky in every stadium, avoiding the long, boring “inconclusive” evidence disruptions that we see in almost every NFL game.

A number of plays in the Giants and A's games last week showed the need for advanced replay — kudos to baseball for its willingness to push the game into the 21st century. But if it's going to take this leap, it needs to get the call right the first time and establish review umpires in every stadium.

Paul Gackle is a contributor to The San Francisco Examiner. He can be reached at and followed on Twitter @GackleReport.

Major League BaseballPaul GackleReplay

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at

Just Posted

Gov. Gavin Newsom speaks at a COVID-19 update at the City College of San Francisco mass vaccination site in April. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
Gavin Newsom under COVID: The governor dishes on his pandemic life

By Emily Hoeven CalMatters It was strange, after 15 months of watching… Continue reading

Deputy public defender Chris Garcia outside the Hall of Justice on Wednesday, June 16, 2021. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
As pandemic wanes, SF public defender hopes clients will get ‘their day in court’

Like other attorneys in San Francisco, Deputy Public Defender Chris Garcia has… Continue reading

Hyphen hosts a group show at Space Gallery in San Francisco in 2010. (Photo courtesy of Albert Law/Pork Belly Studio)
What’s in a name? Asian American magazine fights to keep its identity

An investor-backed media group laid claim to the moniker of SF’s long-running Hyphen magazine, sparking a conversation about writing over community history

A warning notice sits under the windshield wiper of a recreational vehicle belonging to a homeless man named David as it sits parked on De Wolf Street near Alemany Boulevard on Friday, Aug. 31, 2018. A proposed SF Municipal Transportation Agency law would make it illegal for overnight parking on the side street for vehicles taller than seven feet or longer than 22 feet. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Fight over ‘poverty tows’ heats up

‘What can we do to ensure the vehicle stays in the hands of the owner?’

Crab fisherman Skip Ward of Marysville casts his crab net out off a pier near Fort Point. (Craig Lee/Special to The	Examiner)
San Francisco came back to life, and we captured it all

Last spring, in the early days of the pandemic, the bestselling authors… Continue reading

Most Read