‘The lady doth protest too much’

Larry Bush wrote a sloppy op-ed ostensibly about Proposition C. Although it does not affect us at the San Francisco Bay Area Renters Federation (SFBARF), Larry tripped all over himself on his way to mentioning us, confusing Yelp with Airbnb, and not knowing that the Renters PAC isn’t a 501(c)(3). That’s pretty embarrassing.

This is the second op-ed he’s written where he superfluously dragged us into his story. Why is SFBARF keeping Larry up at night?

Here’s our guess: SFBARF is the housing obstructionist’s worst nightmare.

Underbuilding is not sustainable. Population growth must be accommodated by housing growth. It’s not just a matter of economics, it’s a matter of trying to fit too many objects into too few containers. Suppressing housing didn’t suppress job creation. S.F. created 100,000 jobs since 2010, but only 8,000 homes. The people who would have lived in the housing we failed to build didn’t fail to arrive. We’re here now, fighting with each other for scraps of housing, and we’re pissed.

When I started going to the planning commission, I had no idea that it would strike a chord with so many people. I don’t have to spend money convincing people of anything. The experience of shortage conditions is convincing enough. Renters show up to see apartments only to find they are competing with dozens of others. Lived experience is radicalizing. They see that we don’t have enough housing to go around, and the only way out is more housing.

It’s not surprising that amateurs emerged to say, “No more denials, let’s get housing built.”

Lived experience is a hard thing to argue against. The obstructionists have a difficult task: How do you convince victims of a shortage that the shortage is good?

Larry’s piece is an example of their desperation. In the absence of a compelling argument, they’re trying to “poison the well.” This is a rhetorical move that makes it impossible for your opponent to participate in the debate.

Imagine you have a community of people, and you face a political question, “A or B?”

A political operative polls the community on the question. If someone picks “B,” she’s told this reveals her to be an outsider. The operative announces that all community members prefer A and that he has discovered there are many infiltrators in their midst.

This is the housing conversation. As soon as someone reveals that she believes S.F. needs to build housing, she is cast as an infiltrator. It’s a neat trick, but we aren’t idiots; we see through it.

This poisons the well because “the well” is a shared resource — the space of political debate — and the poisoner is willing to destroy the space by refusing to recognize the other participants as community members.

By accusing sincere political participants of being paid actors, S.F.’s conservatives are driving us away.

They spin conspiracy theories
about “dark money” because they can’t come to grips with the real reason they’re losing influence: Their message ignores the lived experiences of thousands. Instead of trying to
engage, the conservatives tell us we are infiltrators. They can’t figure out why their message is unpopular because they’ve poisoned the well. They really don’t believe there are ordinary people who want to see more housing built.

It’s bad for us to feel disenfranchised by this trick, but in the long run, it’ll be worse for the conservatives. We get our feelings hurt, but the conservatives are on the path to irrelevance. They poisoned the well, and now it’s all they have to drink from.

Sonja Trauss is the founder of the SFBA Renters Federation and SFBA Renters PAC. Armand Domalewski is the Co-Chair of the Progress Democratic Club of San Francisco.

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

Crab fisherman Skip Ward of Marysville casts his crab net out off a pier near Fort Point. (Craig Lee/Special to The	Examiner)
San Francisco came back to life, and we captured it all

Last spring, in the early days of the pandemic, the bestselling authors… Continue reading

Revelers at Madrone Art Bar in the early hours of June 15, 2021 (Courtesy Power Quevedo).
No social distancing at Motown-themed dance party

‘I don’t care how anyone feels, I just want to dance!’

<em>The San Francisco Peace Pagoda stands tall in between Japan Center East and West malls.</em>
 (Ida Mojadad/The Examiner)
Patrons return to the Japantown mall

‘We’re so happy—it’s really hard to make a profit’

Scenes from an SFO-bound BART train on Tuesday, June 15, 2021, the day California fully reopened for business after the COVID pandemic. (Al Saracevic/SF Examiner)
SF reopens: BART riders dreading the end of the pandemic

‘I’ve forgotten what it’s like to be packed like sardines’

Micael Butial stands as he holds an umbrella that he painted with the words “Stop Asian Hate” at a rally held to show support for Asian and Pacific Islanders communities, Sunday, March 21, 2021 in San Francisco. (Photo by Ekevara Kitpowsong/Special to S.F. Examiner)
Inside the California organization tracking anti-Asian hate incidents

By Mallika Seshadri CalMatters Richard Lim was walking along a quiet sidewalk… Continue reading

Most Read