The findings of a federal judge deal health care law a setback

Almost from the moment of its passage last March, the Obama administration’s signature health care law has been under attack.

More than 20 lawsuits have been filed challenging the law. The administration won the first two, in eastern Michigan and western Virginia. But in the eastern district of Virginia, the state’s conservative attorney general got the case before a notably conservative federal judge and the opponents finally got the ruling they wanted.

U.S. District Judge Henry Hudson ruled as unconstitutional a key, even vital, provision of the bill: the requirement that individuals must buy health insurance or pay a penalty. That mandate, he ruled, “exceeds the constitutional boundaries of congressional power.”

It will be interesting to see how the higher courts deal with his key findings. The dispute, Hudson said, is not about how best to craft universal health coverage, “it’s about an individual’s right to choose to participate.” The history of when and how individuals can opt out of government mandates, usually on religious grounds, is long and complicated and heavily weighted in favor of the government.

Hudson also said the insurance mandate, if allowed to stand, “would invite the unbridled exercise of federal police powers.” That seems a little overwrought, although given the government’s growing fixation on health — fatty foods, alcohol, tobacco, exercise — perhaps not.

By spreading the insurance risk as broadly as possible, the individual mandate makes possible two of the law’s most popular provisions: a ban on insurers denying coverage for pre-existing conditions and a requirement that insurers charge roughly similar prices for coverage.

Hudson thoughtfully did not enjoin the government from implementing the mandate, but did say he expected the Justice Department to honor his decision. He also helpfully declared that the mandate could be “severed” from the rest of the Affordable Care Act, meaning that the whole law would not be found unconstitutional if only one part of it was found to be so.

Virginia would like its case to be the one deciding the fate of health care reform. Three ambitious conservative Virginia politicians — Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli, Gov. Bob McDonnell and incoming House Majority Leader Eric Cantor — are trying to persuade governors and governors-elect to pressure U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder to fast track the case, bypassing the appeals process to go directly to the Supreme Court.

Perhaps adding to their sense of urgency, a much larger case — to which 20 states are party — is under way in a Florida federal court with a decision expected early next year.

Also, opponents of the law might sense that the Obama administration is right and that once the public becomes aware of the law’s benefits, support for retaining it may begin to build.

But given the political sensitivity of the health care law and the gravity of the issues, the appeals process should be meticulously followed. The law should not be rushed through the courts, or even appear to be rushed. There is no hurry. The individual mandate does not take effect until 2014.

Dale McFeatters is a columnist with Scripps Howard News Service.


Barack ObamaOp Edsop-edOpinion

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

Organizer Jas Florentino, left, explains the figures which represent 350 kidnapped Africans first sold as slaves in the United States in 1619 in sculptor Dana King’s “Monumental Reckoning.” The installation is in the space of the former Francis Scott Key monument in Golden Gate Park. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
What a reparations program would look like in The City

‘If there’s any place we can do it, it’s San Francisco’

Officer Joel Babbs at a protest outside the Hall of Justice in 2017 (Bay City News file photo)
The strange and troubling story of Joel Babbs: What it tells us about the SFPD

The bizarre and troubling career of a whistle-blowing San Francisco police officer… Continue reading

Bay Area soul and jazz great Ledisi headlined Stern Grove’s opening 2021 show. (Christopher Victorios/Special to The Examiner)
Sweet sounds, extra space at Stern Grove

Ledisi, The Seshen, La Doña play first free concert since pandemic hit

Gov. Gavin Newsom speaks at a COVID-19 update at the City College of San Francisco mass vaccination site in April. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
Gavin Newsom under COVID: The governor dishes on his pandemic life

By Emily Hoeven CalMatters It was strange, after 15 months of watching… Continue reading

People fish at a dock at Islais Creek Park on Thursday, June 10, 2021. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
What Islais Creek tells us about rising sea levels in San Francisco

Islais Creek is an unassuming waterway along San Francisco’s eastern industrial shoreline,… Continue reading

Most Read