No on 82: wrong fix for preschool

There can be no doubt that a well-educated work force is vital for California’s continued competitiveness in the global economy. And there also seems little doubt that attending preschool provides important advantages for children entering kindergarten, especially when it comes to overcoming the achievement gap for 4-year-olds from a lower-income or non-native-English-speaking background.

However, there is much room for doubt as to whether the expensive and cumbersome bureaucracy proposed by the $2.4 billion Proposition 82 universal preschool program could truly deliver much of what it promises.

That’s why voters should reject Prop. 82 and send the measure back to the drawing board.

All costs of Prop. 82 supposedly would be paid by a 1.7 percent tax on families earning more than $800,000 a year, providing free preschool for every California 4-year-old.

But high-end income taxes are known to be an extremely volatile revenue source as they reflect economic fluctuations. Thus Prop. 82 would allow the Legislature to impose tuition fees on preschool families to cover program costs. The free lunch promised by Prop. 82 supporters could become illusory for many taxpayers.

Even worse, many of the sunny claims in Prop. 82 seem based on highly shaky educational and financial assumptions about preschool benefits.

A 2005 RAND Corporation study warned that preschool for advantaged children is not proven to “necessarily translate into gains in eventual educational attainment — as it appears to do for more-disadvantaged children.” And a 2006 UC Santa Barbara report concluded that the preschool head-start effect on disadvantaged children fades away after a few years in badly performing elementary schools.

The promised affordability of Prop. 82 is also hard to believe. Quebec instituted universal preschool in 1998, promoting it as costing $230 million over five years. That cost has now ballooned to $1.7 billion per year, partially attributable to a 40 percent pay hike for a daycare employees union that threatened to strike.

Only a few years ago, spending more money to reduce class size was touted as a kind of magic bullet to dramatically improve student achievement. As we have all seen, that solution did not work. Now universal preschool is being sold as the next magic bullet.

California has already seen repeated demonstrations that using emotional voter referendums to divide a finite annual budget is bad for the state. Every general-fund dollar mandated to agood cause such as education or improving the highways means a dollar is snatched away from other good causes such as creating more group housing to keep mentally ill indigents off the streets or repairing fragile flood-control levees. Vote no on Prop. 82.

General OpinionOpinion

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

Harlan Kelly, head of the SFPUC and husband to City Administrator Naomi Kelly (right), faces federal charges for allegedly trading inside information on a city contract in return for a paid family vacation. (Courtesy photo)
Harlan Kelly, head of SFPUC, charged with fraud in widening Nuru scandal

Kelly accused of engaging in corrupt partnership with permit expediter

Jeff Tumlin, director of transportation for the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency, said the agency’s fiscal situation is “far worse” than the worse case scenarios projected back in April. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
SFMTA prepares for massive potential layoffs as budget crisis continues to build

More than 1,200 full-time jobs on the line as agency struggles to close deficit

California Gov. Gavin Newsom is weighing further restrictions as COVID-19 cases rise. (Genaro Molina/Pool/Los Angeles Times/TNS)
Newom considering new shelter-in-place order as COVID-19 cases rise

Gov. Gavin Newsom on Monday warned that he may need to reinstate… Continue reading

Nicole Canedo looks at her City-issued Medical Reimbursement Account page on her computer outside her Berkeley apartment on Tuesday, Nov. 24, 2020. Canedo has worked numerous retail jobs in The City and the MRA has helped her with health costs. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Millions left sitting in medical reimbursement accounts by city workers

Health officials looking at how to improve access, outreach as untapped funds reach $409M

Andrew Faulk wrote "My Epidemic." (Courtesy photo)
Doctor’s memoir a fitting remembrance for World AIDS Day

‘My Epidemic’ tells personal stories of men who died

Most Read