Letters: Does a possible Brown Act violation justify pulling a false fire alarm?

A police sergeant facing misdemeanor charges may have had good reason for her actions

Does a possible Brown Act violation justify pulling a false fire alarm?

When a KGO-TV news crew ambushed San Francisco Police Sergeant Maria Teresa Donati at her MTA service window and asked why she pulled a false fire alarm at Pacifica Police headquarters, where a city task force was holding a closed-door meeting about homelessness, she replied, “It’s clear,” before pulling down the shade on her window and walking away.

Cryptic words until you think about it. Maybe Donati’s action that night was not that of a frustrated child who wasn’t allowed into the game, but rather that of someone who believed that a Brown Act violation was taking place — and so the meeting had to be stopped at any cost.

Suddenly, her “it’s clear” has clarity.

And what was the least harmful way to stop a meeting that had to be stopped? A Pacifica Police captain already had told Donati to go away — that the meeting was private. The next-best least-harmful way, so she thought, was to activate a false fire alarm. Point is, in Donati’s mind, the meeting had to be stopped.

The success of this defense depends largely on whether you can convince a jury that a city task force meeting about homelessness, held in private in Pacifica in possible violation of the Brown Act, poses a threat to the American way of life.

To win her case, Donati certainly would have to take the stand to express her support of the Brown Act and her reasoning that to uphold it justifies pulling a fire alarm.

If Donati has the oratorical skills to invoke matters of principle, slippery slopes, and totalitarian regimes that got their start at closed-door meetings, I believe she could pull it off. And if she succeeds, it could become a landmark case.

Alan Wald

Pacifica

Just Posted

New SFMTA director’s tweets show aversion to free parking, cars

The City’s new transit leader has a bumpy relationship with cars. Jeffrey… Continue reading

Advocates say Academy of Art deal ignores needs of students with disabilities

The needs of students with disabilities are being ignored in a proposed… Continue reading

City stalls request for more parking for 911 dispatchers, citing ‘Transit First’ policy

SFMTA board says city staff should be ‘leading by example,’ discouraged from driving

Recall effort against Fewer panned as ‘PR stunt’

Signature drive inspired by anti-SFPOA chant faces ‘procedural hurdles,’ little support

SF to ward off emerging technology dangers by launching new regulatory office

Board president Norman Yee says innovation must ‘provide a net common good’

Most Read