High-speed rail lawsuit will settle bond issue once and for all

The California High-Speed Rail Authority is using a legal maneuver to shield itself from future lawsuits over its bond allocation. This is a wise move that will keep this important project moving ahead.

The lawsuit, unveiled last week in Sacramento Superior Court, would force anyone who takes issue with the legality of the bond issuance to argue his or her case during a yet-to-be scheduled hearing at which the state Attorney General’s Office will defend the authority, the San Jose Mercury News reported. Dan Richard, the chairman of the authority’s board of directors, told The San Francisco Examiner on Wednesday that the move is meant to validate the action of issuing bonds all at once in one hearing instead of having lawsuits endlessly drag out in courts across the state. Once the matter is settled, no one would be able to sue over these bonds again.

While some might argue that this move by the authority is an attempt to silence opponents of the project, the truth is that the legal tactic, which has been used by other municipalities over bond issuances, will give opponents a very specific time window during which they can argue their cases before a judge. The controversial project seems certain to face many other lawsuits as it moves forward — especially over land acquisitions and environmental impact reports — so it makes sense that officials would want to resolve the legality of the bonds issued for construction of a segment of Central Valley rail line and then move on to other issues.

Richard, who spoke about the project at the Commonwealth Club of California on Wednesday, did not shy away from talking about why the project has become such a lightning rod in the past few years. But he also was blunt about why California needs high-speed rail, and he is right. As he points out, the state’s population is expected to grow dramatically in the next few generations, and smart transportation and land-use choices will be necessary for the state to accommodate all this growth. High-speed rail should be a central intersection of both issues. It is worth an investment now into a rail system that can move people in the future without generating more carbon emissions.

A lot still needs to be settled when it comes to this high-speed rail project, which is the first of its kind in the United States. But the larger good that will come from this project once it is finished will far outweigh the short-term issues that must be overcome. As with any large-scale project — and this is one of the largest in California history — there will be negative impacts, and the authority must work to mitigate those to the fullest extent. Worthwhile discussions remain to be had about course alignment and station locations, but the bond issue should be settled quickly so those more important discussions about the project can continue.

California High Speed Rail AuthorityeditorialsHigh speed railOpinion

Just Posted

A woman carries an umbrella while walking along Market Street as a light rain falls on Wednesday, Oct. 20, 2021. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
The storm door is open in San Francisco: What will the rains bring?

‘Come Monday, fire season in Northern California should be done’

The Walgreens at 4645 Mission St. in The City is among those slated to close. <ins>(Courtesy photo)</ins>
Walgreens says it’s closing five SF stores due to crime. Where’s the data?

Walgreens should be transparent, enlighten city leaders about crime’s effect on business

While some pedestrians enjoy walking on the car-free Great Highway, others, who drive to work, want the road reopened full-time to vehicles. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
Converting the Great Highway into a Great Walkway makes no sense

It’s helpful to take a detailed look at the environmental and transit effects

Stephen Curry and Draymond Green of the Warriors hope to vie for another title in the 2021-22 NBA season. (Chris Victorio/Special to The Examiner)
Warriors and Lakers analysis: Two teams, two approaches

While L.A. has been a tear-down project, the Golden State has been busy remodeling

Most Read