Examiner Editorial: Race to the Top winners have poor records

Second-round finalists of the Obama administration’s signature Race to the Top education reform program, including Maryland and the District of Columbia, are receiving millions of federal stimulus dollars to improve their struggling public schools. But an inherently flawed process does not bode well for the program’s ultimate success. The competition’s welcome transparency (semifinalists’ applications, scores and video presentations were posted online) does not alter the fact that states making the greatest progress enacting the kind of reforms that the $3.4 billion program is supposed to promote were not rewarded for their efforts.

For example, a Fordham Institute study ranks New Orleans’ Recovery School District as the top “reform-friendly” school district in the nation. Critics point to Louisiana’s absence from the winner’s circle as proof that things other than successful academic reform and innovation were rewarded. Colorado led the nation in education reform, including the promotion of charter schools, merit pay, data-based standards and linking teacher evaluations to student achievement, but also somehow failed to make the final cut. New Jersey’s 1,000-page application was tossed out for a clerical error.

Yet Maryland, which was ranked 35th in data quality and 40th in the promotion of charter schools, is a finalist. So is New York, even though the Empire State initially failed to meet the program’s basic requirements and was rocked earlier this month by revelations of a state testing scandal. Both Maryland and D.C., which is also a finalist, have long histories of educational failure. Maryland followed the Thornton Commission’s recommendation to increase education spending by a whopping $1.3 billion over the past decade, but the outlays did virtually nothing for students in Prince George’s County and Baltimore, and failed to put much of a dent in the minority achievement gap in Montgomery County. The D.C. public schools spend more per student than any other district in the country, but its students are still performing well below the national average, despite Chancellor Michelle Rhee’s deservedly lauded three-year attempt to turn things around.

Fordham Institute president Chester Finn Jr. acknowledges that “some places that don’t deserve it are being rewarded. Some that merit gold medals for their reform efforts … are instead punched in the nose.” He gives Education Secretary Arne Duncan a “B” for initiating the Race for the Top competition, which he says has “catalyzed a large amount of worthwhile education-reform activity in a great many places.” That may be so, but why pour additional billions of tax dollars into public school districts with lousy track records while ignoring systems that have demonstrated records of success?

editorialseducationOpinionSFExaminer

Just Posted

Dominion Voting Systems, a Denver-based vendor, is under contract to supply voting machines for elections in San Francisco. (Kevin N. Hume/Examiner file)
Is San Francisco’s elections director impeding voting machine progress?

Open source technology could break up existing monopoly

The 49ers take on the Packers in Week 3 of the NFL season, before heading into a tough stretch of divisional opponents. (Courtesy San Francisco 49ers)
‘Good for Ball’ or ‘Bad for Ball’ — A Niners analysis

By Mychael Urban Special to The Examiner What’s the first thing that… Continue reading

Health experts praised Salesforce for keeping its Dreamforce conference at Moscone Center outdoors and on a small scale. (Kevin N. Hume/The Examiner)
Happy birthday, Marc Benioff. Your company did the right thing

Salesforce kept Dreamforce small, which made all kinds of sense

Former San Francisco Mayor Willie Brown, pictured with Rose Pak in 2014, says the late Chinatown activist was “helping to guide the community away from the divisions, politically.”
Willie and Rose: How an alliance for the ages shaped SF

How the Mayor and Chinatown activist shaped San Francisco, then and now

The Grove in Golden Gate Park is maintained largely by those who remember San Francisco’s 20,000 AIDS victims.<ins> (Open Eye Pictures/New York Times)</ins>
Looking at COVID through the SF prism of AIDS

AIDS took 40 years to claim 700,000 lives. COVID surpassed that number in 21 months

Most Read