BART, SamTrans must work it out

The ongoing money dispute between Bay Area Rapid Transit and the San Mateo County Transit District is heating up again, with ugly ultimatums flying back and forth between the two agencies.

BART insists SamTrans owes it $11.2 million next year to repay operating losses of the extension line to San Francisco International Airport. SamTrans counters that it won’t pay a cent more than $5 million and will never make another payment after next year.

The problem began when the BART-SFO extension was being negotiated during the 1990s. San Mateo County wanted commuter stations along the Peninsula route and costlier underground tracks. A partnership was formed that obligated SamTrans to pay any BART-SFO operating losses in exchange for retaining all future profits from the extension line.

In hindsight, this proved to be a bad deal for SamTrans. The extension went into service just in time for SFO air travel and Peninsula commuting to be hit by the double blow of Sept. 11 and the dot-com recession. Therefore ridership has always been significantly below the euphoric expectations of the prosperous late ’90s.

Overall the Peninsula ridership numbers appear to be slowly rising, although recently BART and SamTrans have been releasing contradictory figures about whether passenger numbers are going up or down. However, there is no argument that the SFO extension is still a long way from breaking even.

The BART-SFO line has been a significant drain on both transit agencies. SamTrans is currently facing a $24.7 million deficit primarily due to a sales tax revenue drop and rising costs for fuel and health benefits. SamTrans’ bus fare was raised 25 cents last September and service was reduced. In 2004, SamTrans refused to pay any of the $15 million BART demanded. BART threatened a lawsuit and the two parties settled for $10 million.

It seems pointless for the western Bay Area’s primary transit providers to continue engaging in such consistent brinkmanship. What should happen now is for both agencies to come to the bargaining table and renegotiate an agreement that makes sense under today’s realities. SamTrans clearly cannot afford to continue paying seven-figure subsidies. BART could possibly end with even less money received from a public agency forced into declaring insolvency.

The most reasonable new approach might be for BART to delay collection of a substantial portion of the operating subsidy. Then, if and when the SFO extension ever begins turning a profit, those revenues would first go toward paying the uncollected subsidies before SamTrans gets a cent. For the sake of the riders, the agencies must get their act together and move forward with a realistic plan.

General OpinionOpinion

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

District Attorney Chesa Boudin announces charges against former SFPD Officer Christopher Samoyoa in the 2017 fatal shooting of Keita O’Neill at a press conference outside the Hall of Justice on Monday, Nov. 23, 2020. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
DA Boudin charges fired SFPD officer with manslaughter over fatal shooting

Ex-Officer Christopher Samayoa to face criminal charges in killing of Keita O’Neil

The area near the Castro Muni Metro Station is expected to be affected by construction work on the Twin Peaks Tunnel, with lane closures on Market Street and some loss of parking. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Construction on Twin Peaks Tunnel to begin November 30

Area around Castro Muni Station will see greatest impacts including lane closures on Market Street

(Genaro Molina/Pool/Los Angeles Times/TNS)
Newsom calls latest surge of COVID-19 cases ‘unprecendented’

By Eli Walsh Bay City News Foundation California’s latest surge of COVID-19… Continue reading

Dr. Barbara Ferrer, director of the Los Angeles County Department of Public Health, during a news conference on March 10, 2020. (Myung J. Chun/Los Angeles Times/TNS)
LA County suspends outdoor dining at restaurants as coronavirus surges

By Alex Wigglesworth Los Angeles Times Los Angeles County public health officials… Continue reading

Renderings of the main entrance to upcoming Mission Bay elementary school on Owens Street. (Courtesy photo)
SFUSD offers first look at planned Mission Bay elementary school

San Francisco school officials this month unveiled the design of a planned… Continue reading

Most Read