Was Deborah Madden's confession a move to keep her city pension?

AP File PhotoFormer crime lab technician Deborah Madden

On March 15, disgraced former San Francisco crime lab technician Deborah Madden pleaded guilty to misdemeanor cocaine possession.

Remember that Madden was charged with felony drug possession and admitted under oath that she took cocaine from the lab, but maintained that it was extra stuff that fell off the scale. Felony drug possession requires proof of fraud, and neither of the two juries that heard the case could agree unanimously that Madden got the drug by deception since she had legitimate access to it by virtue of her job.

So after two trials, Madden pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor, saying, “I knowingly possessed cocaine outside the scope of my employment.”

Why the “outside the scope of my employment” part? I suspect that’s how Madden — a 29-year lab employee — plans to keep her pension and benefits.

Per the City Charter, an employee cannot lose the amount that he or she has paid into a retirement fund. That is safe, no matter what. But people can be stripped of the taxpayer-funded part if they are convicted of a crime “involving moral turpitude in connection with his or her duties.”

In this case, Madden also claimed that an unnamed “friend” also gave her a small amount of the drug, so she’s only pleading guilty to that possession, which was “outside the scope” of her employment. In doing so, despite causing some 600 drug cases to be dismissed and admitting to an egregious breach of the public trust, she must be hoping to continue getting $5,485 per month plus cost-of-living increases for life.

The charter provisions regarding moral turpitude only apply to convictions, not to pleas, so we’ll have to wait until the next hearing in July to see what she’s actually convicted of. Not that there’s any reason to believe it will differ from the plea.

Depending on the conviction, The City’s retirement fund will have the last word on whether Madden has sufficiently tipped the scales in her favor.

Bay Area NewsColumnistsDeborah MaddenLocalMelissa Griffin

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

SF protests continue with Golden Gate Bridge takeover, Mission march and more

Nearly two weeks after death of George Floyd, thousands turn out to demand justice and reform

Officer who knelt with George Floyd protesters accused of insubordination a day later

Rubin Rhodes, a black officer who identifies as non-binary, sent home for wearing earrings

SF officer involved in shooting death of homeless man quit while facing discipline, landed new job in Antioch

An officer who faced discipline for needlessly escalating a confrontation that led… Continue reading

Most Read