Transportation agency might ban disputed ads

Mike Koozmin/The S.F. ExaminerControversial advertisements on Muni buses has spurred a signature-gathering effort to remove the signs.

In an effort to avoid recent controversies that have beset Muni and BART, Golden Gate Transit is poised to adopt an advertising policy barring political and religious campaigns, but some observers say the rule would trample First Amendment rights.

For years, the transit agency, which is managed by the Golden Gate Bridge, Highway and Transportation District, has used an informal set of guidelines for determining whether to accept advertisements, spokeswoman Mary Currie said. On Friday, the district’s board of directors will vote to formally adopt a policy, which would include a new ban against religious and political ads.

Friday’s vote follows contentious debate at Muni and BART regarding political advertisements involving opposing views of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. A recent campaign on Muni regarding the subject was controversial enough for the agency to donate all proceeds from the ads to the San Francisco Human Rights Commission.

“In light of that, we were certainly prompted to look at how we handle our advertising,” Currie said. “We wanted our buses to remain as neutral as possible for our passengers. We believe our ads should only be commercial in nature.”

Currie said various courts have ruled that transit agencies may keep their vehicles closed to expressive activities and thereby limit advertising to just commercial campaigns.

“We’re confident this does not violate any First Amendment laws,” she said.

But University of San Francisco law professor Josh Davis said a recent decision by the New York Metropolitan Transportation Authority to reject political advertising was ruled unconstitutional by a federal judge.

“This looks like an awkward strategy, at best, by the transit district,” Davis said.

Joseph Tuman, a communications professor at San Francisco State University, said the new policy may skirt the First Amendment. If a legal challenge were brought against the policy and a judge were to rule that agency buses and ferries are public places, then the district would have to go to great lengths to prove the ban against religious and political advertisements was of great public importance, Tuman said.

However, if a judge deemed the buses and ferries to be nonpublic places, then the district would simply have to provide a reasonable explanation — the desire to avoid controversy — for its policy decision.

In similar cases elsewhere, Tuman said, courts have ruled that buses are nonpublic places — although legal interpretations vary.

In additional to barring political and religious ads, the transportation district’s new policy would also outlaw campaigns that are false or misleading, obscene or defamatory, advocate crime, infringe on copyrights, or promote cigarettes or alcohol.

The new policy would only apply to the district bus and ferry fleet. Expressive activities, including political demonstrations, would still be allowed on district property, Currie said.

wreisman@sfexaminer.com

BARTBay Area NewsLocalTransittransportationUniversity of San Francisco

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

The City is seeking to enhance health care for San Francisco International Airport workers, which include more than 100 who have tested positive for COVID-19. <ins>(Courtesy photo)</ins>
Airlines, business groups fight new health insurance requirements for SFO workers

Heathy Airport Ordinance would require companies to offer family coverage or increase contributions

The Hall of Justice building at 850 Bryant St. is notorious for sewage leaks and is known to be seismically unsafe. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
SFPD speeding up Hall of Justice exit after another ‘large leak’

San Francisco police can’t get out of the decrepit Hall of Justice… Continue reading

The Telegraph Quartet is pictured during its SF Music Day 2020 recording session at the striking, beautifully lit and almost empty Herbst Theatre. (Courtesy Marcus Phillips)
SF Music Day goes virtual with Herbst broadcast

Performers pre-record sets in empty, iconic theater

Dr. Vincent Matthews, superintendent of the San Francisco Unified School District, said Tuesday that student would not be back in school before the end of this calendar year. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Superintendent: City schools will not reopen before the end of the year

San Francisco public schools won’t reopen to students for the rest of… Continue reading

The admissions process at the academically competitive Lowell High School is set to change this year due to coronavirus restritions. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Lowell’s selective admissions process put on hold this year — and more changes may be in the works

School board votes unanimously to use normal student assignment lottery for competitive school

Most Read