Prosecutors drop bid for $562 million PG&E fine, maximum will be $6 million if convicted

Federal prosecutors in the criminal pipeline safety trial of PG&E Co. in San Francisco on Tuesday suddenly dropped their bid for an enhanced fine of $562 million if the utility is convicted.

Instead, the maximum penalty PG&E could now be given if found guilty of all 12 counts it faces would be $500,000 per count, or a total of $6 million.

The move came as the jury was in its fourth day of deliberations, following a five-and-one-half week trial in the court of U.S. District Judge Thelton Henderson.

Jurors left for the day shortly after 3 p.m. Tuesday and will reconvene at 9 a.m. today.

PG&E is accused of 11 counts of violating pipeline record-keeping, evaluation and testing requirements of the U.S. Natural Gas Pipeline Safety Act for high-pressure transmission lines.

It also faces one count of obstructing a National Transportation Safety Act probe into the fatal rupture and explosion of a defectively welded transmission pipeline in San Bruno in 2010. Eight people died and a neighborhood was leveled in the blast and ensuing fire.

In a 2014 indictment, prosecutors originally sought an enhanced fine under the federal Alternative Sentencing Act.

In the event of a conviction, that law would have allowed a fine of double the profit PG&E gained from the alleged crimes. The indictment alleged the base amount of such profit was $281 million, making a potential total of $562 million when doubled.

Tuesday’s move means that the possible fine, if PG&E is convicted, would be the amount normally set by the pipeline safety and obstruction laws: $500,000 per count, or a total maximum of $6 million.

Prosecutors announced the change in a two-page filing, which did not give a reason. U.S. Attorney’s Office spokesperson Abraham Simmons said he could not comment on the change.

PG&E spokesperson Greg Snapper said, “Regardless of this action or the next legal steps, we want our customers and their families to know that we are committed to re-earning their trust by acting with integrity and working around the clock to provide them with energy that is safe, reliable, affordable and clean.”

The disclosure of prosecutors’ change of heart came amid recent disputes between PG&E and the federal lawyers about how an alternative fine could be calculated and whether the fine would be determined by the current jury or by a new, second jury if PG&E were convicted.

In a brief filed on Saturday, PG&E attorneys argued that the profit PG&E gained from specific violations “would be impossible to isolate and quantify.”

In a separate civil proceeding, the California Public Utilities Commission last year fined PG&E $1.6 billion in three cases concerning the San Bruno explosion, pipeline record-keeping and maintenance of pipelines in high-population areas.Bay Area NewsPG&EThelton Henderson

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

After the pandemic hit, Twin Peaks Boulevard was closed to vehicle traffic, a situation lauded by open space advocates. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
New proposal to partially reopen Twin Peaks to vehicles pleases no one

Neighbors say closure brought crime into residential streets, while advocates seek more open space

Protesters rally at the site of a proposed affordable housing project at 2550 Irving St. in the Sunset District on Saturday, Jan. 23, 2021. (Ming Vong/S.F. Examiner)
Sunset District affordable housing discussion flooded with ‘scare tactics and hysteria’

Project would provide 100 units, some of which would be designated for formerly homeless families

Members of the Sheriff’s Department command staff wore masks at a swearing-in ceremony for Assistant Sheriff Tanzanika Carter. One attendee later tested positive. 
Courtesy SFSD
Sheriff sees increase in COVID-19 cases as 3 captains test positive

Command staff among 10 infected members in past week

Rainy weather is expected in the coming week. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Rainstorms, potential atmospheric river expected to drench Bay Area in coming week

By Eli Walsh Bay City News Foundation Multiple rainstorms, cold temperatures some… Continue reading

U.S. Poet Laureate Amanda Gorman’s powerful reading was among the highlights of Inauguration Day. (Kent Nishimura/Los Angeles Times/TNS)
Inauguration shines light in this never-ending shade

Here’s to renewal and resolve in 2021 and beyond

Most Read