RICH PEDRONCELLI/ap file photoCalifornia Public Utilities Commission President Michael Peevey

RICH PEDRONCELLI/ap file photoCalifornia Public Utilities Commission President Michael Peevey

PG&E faces penalty for emails revealing ‘judge-shopping’

California should ban all back-channel contacts between the state's largest utility and the utility's state regulators, groups representing rate-payers and others urged a state administrative judge Tuesday after the release of emails showing regulators and utility executives secretly negotiating rate cases and other matters.

Administrative law Judge Hallie Yacknin was hearing proposed penalties in connection with emails released this summer that critics say show California Public Utilities Commission members and staffers and executives of PG&E improperly and privately hashing out agreements on issues regarding rate cases and financial penalties.

Tuesday's hearing was triggered by PG&E's release in September of an email exchange in January in which PG&E successfully lobbied the top staffer of CPUC President Michael Peevey for a change of judges in a rate case.

PG&E also released a new batch of emails Monday, the eve of the hearing. Those emails described Peevey seeking $1.1 million in political and other donations during a 2010 dinner in which he and then-PG&E Vice President Brian Cherry also discussed at least five PG&E regulatory matters before the commission.

While only PG&E was facing penalties Tuesday in what Yacknin, the judge, called the “judge-shopping” case, those speaking Tuesday to urge penalties said the CPUC was at fault as well.

Officials from San Bruno have been among the sharpest critics of PG&E and its regulators since a 2010 PG&E natural gasline blast that killed eight people in the city. PG&E is facing federal criminal charges in connection with the explosion.

“Given the controversy that surrounds the commission and the lack of trust … all urge the commission to spend the time and effort necessary to change your way of business,” said Steven Meyers, an attorney representing San Bruno.

The CPUC says it initiated a third-party review of its communications with regulators, but it has not otherwise responded to the release of the emails. Neither Peevey nor Gov. Jerry Brown have commented on the actions described in the emails.

PG&E's legal counsel at Tuesday's hearing described the back-channel contacts in the emails as rare events rather than standard practice, and stressed that the utility had let go the three PG&E executives it believed were responsible.

Commissioners also bore responsibility in the judge-shopping case, utility attorney Martin Schenker told Yacknin.

“We don't believe it's appropriate for PG&E to be training commission members on compliance with their rules,” Schenker said.

Yacknin already has said PG&E faces possible financial penalties in the so-called judge-shopping. San Bruno and another PG&E critic, The Utility Reform Network, variously asked Tuesday for the ban on private contacts and for appointment of an independent monitor to oversee contacts between the utility and the CPUC.

The administrative law judge is slated to give her recommendation to the CPUC on the penalties in coming weeks.

Bay Area NewsCalifornia Public Utilities CommissionPeninsulaPG&ESan Bruno

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

Outdoor dining, as seen here at Mama’s on Washington Square in North Beach in September, is expected to resume in San Franisco this week. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
SF to reopen outdoor dining, personal services

San Francisco will allow outdoor dining and other limited business activity to… Continue reading

City College of San Francisco Board member Alan Wong (Courtesy photo)
CCSF board member tests positive for COVID-19 after National Guard deployment

Alan Wong spent eight days in Sacramento protecting State Capitol before Inauguration Day

Giants slugger Barry Bonds smiles as he makes a joke about McCovey Cove as the San Francisco Giants paid tribute to legend Willie McCovey at AT&T Park on Thursday, Nov. 8, 2018. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Ex-Giants star Barry Bonds again falls short of Hall of Fame

After striking out yet again in his bid to join Major League… Continue reading

Patients line up in their cars to receive a shot at The City’s first mass COVID-19 vaccination site at City College of San Francisco on Friday, Jan. 22, 2021. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Legislation would require SF to create a public COVID-19 vaccine plan — fast

San Francisco’s Department of Public Health would have to come up with… Continue reading

Ian Jameson (center) organized a group of tenant rights activists and assembled at the El Monte City Hall to demand that the City Council there pass an eviction moratorium barring all evictions during the coronavirus pandemic on Sunday, March 29, 2020. (Jason Armond / Los Angeles Times)
California would extend eviction protections to June 30 under proposal

Legislation released Monday would also subsidize rent for low-income tenants

Most Read