Video still appearing to show Carlos Argueta waving a knife within moments of allegedly stabbing James Thomas on Sixth and Market streets Sept. 3, 2015 (Courtesy photo).

Murder trial of tenant attorney to begin after legal back and forth

The murder trial of an attorney accused of fatally stabbing a man on Sixth Street is scheduled to begin Tuesday after Public Defender Jeff Adachi fledged weeks of legal battles seeking to get his client off scot free.

Carlos Argueta, a 34-year-old attorney who worked for the Eviction Defense Collaborative, is facing murder and robbery charges for allegedly stabbing James “Rick” Thomas in a drunken tussle over a bag near Market Street on Sept. 3, 2015.

A grand jury indicted Argueta on the charges last year after a judge found there was insufficient evidence for him to face the initial charges of murder, robbery and assault charges at the end of a preliminary hearing in 2016.

Defense attorneys have long argued that Argueta stabbed Thomas in self-defense. But Adachi, who has decided to represent Argueta himself, turned to more unconventional tactics to fight the case in recent weeks.

Since accusing a prosecutor of misconduct on Sept. 7 in a motion to dismiss the indictment, the public defender has alleged that a judge, who he does not want to decide on whether to throw out the case, is biased against Latinos.

Adachi escalated the tension last Tuesday when he hired a polygraph examiner to test a Latina deputy public defender who claimed that Judge Ethan Schulman once asked her during another case, “When is this telenovela going to end?”

Adachi said Deputy Public Defender Elizabeth Camacho passed the test and challenged Schulman to take one.

Schulman has unequivocally denied making the statement, and provided parts of the court record that he said showed he could not have made the statement.

“I would certainly invite Judge Schulman to take a polygraph exam,” Adachi said. “In fact, we’ll pay for it.”

In the midst of all the back-and-forth, the District Attorney’s Office sought a gag order to prevent Adachi and prosecutors from discussing the case Sept. 27.

Prosecutor Adam Maldonado alleged that increasing media coverage is likely to impact the fairness of the trial because of references to the case previously being dismissed, prosecutors lacking evidence and prosecutorial misconduct.

Assistant District Attorney Andrew Ganz, who previously worked on the case, is facing charges at the State Bar Court for allegedly withholding evidence in a murder case out of Solano County.

Adachi based his motion to dismiss on Ganz, who is currently awaiting a verdict in that court.

The motions are still pending.

The Argueta trial is scheduled for Dept. 13 before Judge Samuel Feng.

mbarba@sfexaminer.com Crime

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

Study: Banning cars on Market had minimal effect on side streets

A traffic nightmare. Congestions madness. Carmageddon. Those were the fears voiced by… Continue reading

Police Commission president calls for probe into allegations of ‘rampant’ anti-black bias in SFPD

A newly surfaced email alleging widespread anti-black bias in San Francisco’s police… Continue reading

Breed declares local emergency to counter threat of coronavirus

City officials warn against discrimination while they prepare for the possibility of an outbreak.

Educators warn of possible strike after district calls for budget cuts, layoffs

SFUSD faces up to $31.8 million shortfall in current school year

Sting builds tuneful ‘Last Ship’

Vivid score, great singers buoy pop star’s musical

Most Read