(Mike Koozmin/2014 S.F. Examiner)

Motion to throw out ‘Google Bus’ lawsuit denied, suit moves forward

A motion to throw out a lawsuit challenging The City’s legalization of private commuter shuttles was dismissed this week.

The shuttles, commonly known in San Francisco as “Google Buses,” were challenged under an environmental review by the “Coalition for Fair, Legal and Environmental Transit.” An attorney for tech company Genentech, a company which uses the shuttles, asked Superior Court Judge Garrett Wong to dismiss the case.

At the environmental hearing in November, Genentech attorney Christopher Carr argued the litigants failed to provide evidence they had legal standing to file suit.

“Cleanly, mechanically, there’s just a failure of proof here, your honor,” he said.

In a motion dated Monday, Dec. 14, Judge Wong denied the motion to dismiss. The order didn’t detail a rationale, merely stating “The Motion for Judgment is DENIED (sic).”

Wong then directed the litigants and defendants to file arguments no later than Jan. 22.

The City Attorney’s Office declined to comment.

The city and county of San Francisco, the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency, Google, Yahoo and other tech companies which use private shuttles are defendants in the case, which was brought by private citizens Sara Shortt, Sue Vaughan, the SEIU Local 1021 and other parties for the Coalition of Fair, Legal and Environmental Transit.

To read the motion by Judge Garrett L. Wong, click here.

The coalition argues The City of San Francisco bypassed legally required studies, which may reveal health risks from the diesel shuttles to neighborhoods, pavement stress impacts, as well as displacement of long term residents due to rising rents around shuttle stops.

The coalition also argued the commuter shuttle program violated state vehicle code by allowing private shuttles to use public Muni bus stops.

Rebecca Davis, an attorney for the coalition, told the Examiner, “the defendants attempted a last minute ‘gotcha’ kind of motion,” which ultimately failed.

She feels the coalition has a strong case, and said “It seems the judge was asking the right questions, not only of us but of the defendants. He’s asking for both sides to submit proposed rulings. I think this is a great sign.”

The commuter shuttle pilot program went to court mid-November, and was approved for permanency by the SFMTA the same month.Commuter shuttle pilot programGoogle busSFMTATransit

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

The City is seeking to enhance health care for San Francisco International Airport workers, which include more than 100 who have tested positive for COVID-19. <ins>(Courtesy photo)</ins>
Airlines, business groups fight new health insurance requirements for SFO workers

Heathy Airport Ordinance would require companies to offer family coverage or increase contributions

The Hall of Justice building at 850 Bryant St. is notorious for sewage leaks and is known to be seismically unsafe. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
SFPD speeding up Hall of Justice exit after another ‘large leak’

San Francisco police can’t get out of the decrepit Hall of Justice… Continue reading

The Telegraph Quartet is pictured during its SF Music Day 2020 recording session at the striking, beautifully lit and almost empty Herbst Theatre. (Courtesy Marcus Phillips)
SF Music Day goes virtual with Herbst broadcast

Performers pre-record sets in empty, iconic theater

Dr. Vincent Matthews, superintendent of the San Francisco Unified School District, said Tuesday that student would not be back in school before the end of this calendar year. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Superintendent: City schools will not reopen before the end of the year

San Francisco public schools won’t reopen to students for the rest of… Continue reading

The admissions process at the academically competitive Lowell High School is set to change this year due to coronavirus restritions. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Lowell’s selective admissions process put on hold this year — and more changes may be in the works

School board votes unanimously to use normal student assignment lottery for competitive school

Most Read