Latest decision ends Alioto-Pier’s re-election saga

Supervisor Michela Alioto-Pier’s political career representing the Pacific Heights and Marina neighborhoods will come to an end in four months after she failed to win a legal battle to overturn the opinion that she’s ineligible to seek re-election. 

While uncertainty has surrounded the District 2 race, it was made clear Wednesday: The Nov. 2 ballots were shipped off to the printers without Alioto-Pier listed as a candidate. 

The California Supreme Court denied her request to take up the court case Wednesday. A California Court of Appeal had ruled against Alioto-Pier, saying she was termed out of office, upholding a more than 2-year-old opinion from City Attorney Dennis Herrera. The decision struck down Alioto-Pier’s July 22 legal victory when Superior Court Judge Peter Busch overturned Herrera’s opinion.

Alioto-Pier said she should be allowed to run for another four-year term, but that “while I am disappointed in the outcome, I of course respect the judicial process.”

Alioto-Pier was appointed to the District 2 seat by Mayor Gavin Newsom in January 2004. She was required to run for election in November 2004 and served the remainder of what would have been Newsom’s complete four-year term, ending in January 2007. She was then re-elected to her current four-year term, which ends Jan. 8.

The City Charter says anyone who’s appointed to serve more than a two-year term will be considered to have served a four-year term. But Alioto-Pier said her November 2004 election means she was appointed for a term of less than a year.

Herrera said someone who’s appointed and serves more than two years of a four-year term will be considered to have served a four-year term “whether they stand for election during that period.”

On Nov. 2, voters will decide who will fill the seat. Strong contenders among the six candidates are Janet Reilly, a Golden Gate Bridge transit district board member, and venture capitalist Mark Farrell.

End of the line

The legal wrangling about whether Supervisor Michela Alioto-Pier could run for re-election focused on her time appointed versus elected.

January 2004: Appointed to District 2 seat by Mayor Gavin Newsom on Jan. 26
November 2004: Wins election for January 2005 to January 2007 term after being required by law to run
November 2006: Elected to current term, which runs from January 2007 to January 2011
November 2010: District 2 seat up for election
January 2011: Current term ends

Source: Board of Supervisors

Just Posted

City cuts to long-term mental health beds prompt protest

Elected officials, hospital staff call move to short-term beds for homeless ‘short-sighted’

SFPD sergeant accused of pulling false fire alarm at Pacifica police station

Sgt. Maria Teresa Donati under investigation after meeting on homelessness disrupted

Pelosi comes out against JUUL ballot measure

Local Democratic leadership largely united in opposition to attempt to overturn vaping ban

ACLU warns BART panhandling and busking ban is ‘unconstitutional’ — and could lead to lawsuits

Elected BART leaders are considering banning panhandling and busking — playing music… Continue reading

Jeff Adachi’s family disputes finding that public defender died of toxic drug mix

Independent expert concludes manner of death was natural

Most Read