Group refocuses hospital lawsuit againstdrops

Medical center construction watchdogs drop election office from litigation

BURLINGAME — Hospital watchdog group Peninsula Guardians has dropped part of its lawsuit regarding the new Peninsula Medical Center to focus on what they say is an illegal 50-year lease agreement between the Peninsula Health Care District and Mills-Peninsula Health Services.

Guardians attorney Mitchell Green said Wednesday that the group dropped the San Mateo County Elections Office from its lawsuit because the election “is moot at this point.”

“The core issue of the litigation is about whether they can go out to 50 years for this lease and we maintain that they cannot,” Green said.

Mills-Peninsula on Wednesday, meanwhile, filed a demurrer with the San Mateo County Superior Court in response to the suit, saying that the lease agreement is legal. Mills-Peninsula attorney Harriet Steiner said in the document that a 30-year limit on such leases cited by the Guardians does not apply, in part because the District is not leasing an existing hospital to the organization.

Mills-Peninsula plans to build a $488 million hospital at its own expense that will meet 2013 state-mandated seismic safety standards. Mills-Peninsula will pay the District, which is the landowner, $1.5 million in annual rent in the next 50 years, after which the District plans on buying back the hospital.

In August, an overwhelming majority of 101,000 District voters approved Measure V — a special mail-in ballot vote that sought the public’s OK for a new Peninsula Medical Center, located at 1783 El Camino Real.

Peninsula Guardians, a nonprofit watchdog formed in response to the hospital project, first filed a lawsuit against the County Elections Office, Mills-Peninsula and the District.

District attorney Doug Straus said he also will likely file a demurrer with the court, asserting that the Guardians’ complaint does not have legal grounding, nor does it present a way to fix the perceived problem.

A case management conference for the lawsuit is scheduled for Dec. 6, according to San Mateo County Superior Court records.

tramroop@examiner.com

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

Mohammed Nuru, head of SF Public Works, arrested in FBI corruption probe

A newly released federal complaint has detailed the stunning allegations that led… Continue reading

Housing at San Francisco’s Union Square? Maybe the time has come

This is no fantasy scenario; it’s real…if Sand Hill properties gets its way.

Preston, advocates pressure major landlord to sell buildings to city or nonprofits

San Francisco’s largest owner of rent-controlled properties is unwilling to entertain demands… Continue reading

SF police union calls for federal prosecution of man shot by police

San Francisco’s police union urged federal authorities to intervene Monday after newly… Continue reading

Most Read