Election results defy neighborhood identities

S.F. Examiner File PhotoBig upset: London Breed

With nude protests at City Hall and a steady stream of consumer-product bans, it’s not a stretch to say that San Francisco’s politics are unconventional. But this year’s supervisorial races added a new chapter — with a moderate Democrat and former Willie Brown protege winning one of The City’s most leftist districts, and a progressive candidate narrowly leading the most conservative district.

London Breed pulled off a shocker last week when she beat out a cavalcade of progressives in District 5, which includes the Fillmore, Western Addition and the former hippie haven of Haight-Ashbury. In a race that pitted a bevy of left-leaning politicians against each other in a contest to determine who was a “true progressive,” none of them will end up on the 11-member board.

In San Francisco’s ranked-choice voting system — which allows voters to choose their top, second and third-place picks, and redistributes those votes in a so-called instant runoff when candidates drop off in rounds of counting — many of the second- and third-place votes cast under progressives ended up going to the moderate Breed. University of San Francisco politics professor Corey Cook said that represents a big mistake in the world of ranked-choice tabulation, where loose coalitions among like-minded candidates are necessary to build and sustain an ideological faction.

“She ran the best campaign and she “outperformed her opponents at debates,” Cook said of Breed. “That meant progressives had to line up behind a choice, but they did not select a standard-bearer, and so those votes got splintered.”

Former Board of Supervisors President Aaron Peskin — still considered a progressive leader — said Breed beat out incumbent Supervisor Christina Olague partly because voters couldn’t get past the latter’s status as an appointee of the moderate Mayor Ed Lee.

“This was as much a referendum on Ed Lee in District 5 as it was on progressives in “District 5,” Peskin said. “Ed Lee lost.”
Cook and Peskin refuted the notion that Olague lost simply on her crucial and controversial vote to reinstate fellow progressive Sheriff Ross Mirkarimi after his protracted domestic-violence scandal, which sparked an effort by Lee to remove him from office. The difference, they said, was less dramatic.

“It’s not so much an indictment of ranked-choice voting, it’s the failure of campaigns to use ranked-choice voting,” Cook said.

The same could be said of progressive Board of Education veteran Norman Yee’s narrow lead over labor leader F.X. Crowley in the relatively conservative western District 7 — which is being vacated by termed-out “fiscal hawk” Sean Elsbernd. The two most moderate candidates — Elsbernd’s preferred candidate, Mike Garcia, and journalist Joel Engardio — came in third and fourth, but could possibly have “prevailed had they formed a common cause.

dschreiber@sfexaminer.com

Bay Area NewsLocalRoss Mirkarimisean elsbernd

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

Police release an image a cracked windshield on a Prius that Cesar Vargas allegedly tried to carjack. Vargas, who was shot by police a short time later, can be seen in videos jumping on the windshield and pushing a Muni passenger who disembarked from a bus. (Courtesy SFPD
SFPD releases videos of deadly police shooting

Cesar Vargas killed after reports of carjacking with knife

New legislation would make sure supportive housing tenants don’t pay more than 30 percent of their income for rent.. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner))
Supportive housing tenants could get more help paying the rent

Supportive housing tenants struggling to pay rent could soon see their payments… Continue reading

Organizers of the San Francisco International Arts Festival had planned to use parts of Fort Mason including the Parade Ground, Eucalyptus Grove and Black Point Battery to host performances by about a dozen Bay Area arts groups. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Arts festival sues city over permit denial

Organizer says outdoor performances should be treated like demonstrations, religious gatherings

An oversight body for San Francisco’s mental health programs may be restructured after questions were raised about its management and lack of effectiveness. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Behavioral health oversight body looks for new start — and staff — after mismanagement

Members of an oversight body for San Francisco’s behavioral health programs said… Continue reading

The City requires the recycling or reuse of debris material removed from a construction project site. <ins>(Emma Chiang/Special to S.F. Examiner)</ins>
<ins></ins>
Permits proposed for haulers of construction debris to achieve zero-waste

San Francisco plans to tighten regulations on the disposal of construction and… Continue reading

Most Read