City attorneys: Adequate warning not given on threat to close CCSF

Beth LaBergeThe City College  Chinatown/North Beach Campus at 808 Kearney St on Nov. 7

Beth LaBergeThe City College Chinatown/North Beach Campus at 808 Kearney St on Nov. 7

City College of San Francisco's accreditor lacked clarity regarding the severity of its sanctions against the school, the City Attorney's Office alleged Thursday in the trial to save CCSF from closure.

The City Attorney's Office filed suit against the Accrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges in August last year, a move that temporarily stayed the commission's efforts to revoke the accreditation of CCSF, which remains open and accredited. City attorneys allege CCSF was unfairly evaluated by the ACCJC, and that it was politically biased against the college.

In the fourth day of trial Thursday before Judge Curtis Karnow, a war of words erupted over the commission's 2006 accreditation evaluation report, which warned the college of areas it needed to improve in order to retain its accreditation.

The City Attorney's Office, however, alleged the warnings were not warnings at all, but “recommendations.” The language was so vague, it claimed, that the college did not realize noncompliance would lead to its closure.

Deputy City Attorney Ronald Flynn instructed ACCJC President Barbara Beno to inspect the evaluation report carefully in her third day on the witness stand.

Beno repeatedly maintained the warnings were clear, and backed up by evidence within the report. Flynn tasked her with providing language to back up her denial of vague instructions, which she did not do.

He asked, “It did not tell City College it failed to comply with [two accreditation standards], is that correct?”

She paused, then said “That's correct.”

While CCSF's accreditation woes apparently had their beginnings in 2006, the college did not perceive them as woes at the time. When the accrediting commission re-evaluated the school in 2012, the commission suddenly changed its wording to more dire language related to accreditation actions.

The recommendations transformed into “deficiencies,” which under ACCJC bylaws command a much harsher sanction. CCSF was placed on show-cause status, one step away from losing its accreditation and effectively shuttering.

A sample of one of the original recommendations reads: “To fully meet Standard II.B Student Support Services, the team recommends that the institution systematically assess student support services using student learning outcomes and other appropriate measures to improve the effectiveness of its support services.”

By not following that recommendation, the ACCJC's attorneys allege, the school doomed itself to close.

The U.S. Department of Education has sanctioned the ACCJC for using vague wording, stating “what is not clear … [is] how an institution, an evaluation team, the Commission or the public is to know the difference.”

Beno shrugged off the department's sanction, saying it was “preliminary.”

The ACCJC's attorneys also counter that CCSF misled the commission in its self-evaluation report. The college's own self-evaluation report was “less than honest,” said Gohar Momjian, CCSF's accreditation liaison officer.</p>

But on the witness stand, Momjian also alleged an ACCJC visiting team member was biased against CCSF, and did not listen to evidence she provided that may have saved the college.

Beno has been additionally accused of bias following the ACCJC's decision to close CCSF, but in court she again denied her ability to sway the 19-member commission's decision.

“As a member of the staff, do you make decisions on accreditation?” ACCJC attorney Kenneth Keller asked Beno.

“No, I do not,” she said.

When ACCJC Commissioner Marie B. Smith took the witness stand, an attorney representing the commission asked if she was swayed by Beno to vote to close CCSF.

“No,” she said under penalty of perjury, “it was our responsibility.”

She also said CCSF did not meet all eight of its original sanctions.

“It troubled me,” she said.

But the question of the original intent, clarity and severity of those sanctions remains. The argument is a major leg of the City Attorney's Office central allegations that the ACCJC gave an unfair evaluation of the college.

CCSF's fate may lay in Judge Curtis Karnow's interpretation of a single word: “recommendation.”

Live testimony in the trial to save CCSF ends today. Karnow will then determine a period of time to examine evidence by both parties.

ACCJCBay Area NewsCCSFCity Attorney’s Officeeducation

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

A warning notice sits under the windshield wiper of a recreational vehicle belonging to a homeless man named David as it sits parked on De Wolf Street near Alemany Boulevard on Friday, Aug. 31, 2018. A proposed SF Municipal Transportation Agency law would make it illegal for overnight parking on the side street for vehicles taller than seven feet or longer than 22 feet. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
SFMTA to resume ‘poverty tows’ amid calls to make temporary ban permanent

Fines and fees hurt low-income, homeless residents, but officials say they are a necessary tool

A broad coalition of tenants and housing rights organizers rally at Stanley Mosk Courthouse to protest eviction orders issued against renters Stanley Mosk Courthouse on Wednesday, Sept. 2, 2020, in Los Angeles, CA. (Irfan Khan/Los Angeles Times/TNS)
Federal judge strikes down CDC’s national moratorium on evictions

David Yaffe-Bellany, Noah Buhayar Los Angeles Times A federal judge in Washington… Continue reading

San Francisco Unified School District spends less in the classroom than other large school districts but has more senior administrative staff.
Data shows SFUSD behind other districts on tax funding, classroom spending

With spending cuts on the horizon, school board members are taking a… Continue reading

City Attorney Dennis Herrera is seeking injunctions preventing those arrested on drug dealing charges in the Tenderloin from returning to the area. 
Examiner file photo
Judge to rule on Herrera’s new plan for tackling Tenderloin drug dealing

A San Francisco judge heard arguments Tuesday on whether City Attorney Dennis… Continue reading

A metal strongbox with appliques (circa AD 1-79) from Parco Archeologico di Pompei is among the items on view in “Last Supper in Pompeii: From the Table to the Grave.” (Courtesy Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco)
Legion of Honor reopens with two original exhibitions

Museum showcases ancient objects from Pompeii, bold new sculptures

Most Read