City attorney to appeal federal judge’s ruling against tenant relocation law

San Francisco City Attorney Dennis Herrera on Wednesday announced plans to appeal a decision by a federal judge to invalidate a city law requiring increased relocation payouts to tenants who are evicted under the state Ellis Act.

The announcement comes a day after U.S. District Court Judge Charles R. Breyer struck down The City's tenant relocation law, calling it unconstitutional. The decision is scheduled to take effect Friday. The Ellis Act allows a landlord to evict tenants in order to get out of the rental business.

The ordinance, which went into effect June 1, requires landlords to pay tenants evicted under the Ellis Act the difference between their current rent and the cost to rent the same-sized unit at market value, as a relocation fee. Opponents have argued that under the ordinance, a tenant's relocation payout for an apartment in more expensive city neighborhoods could have reached as high as $100,000, and no restrictions exist on how to use the payment.

Herrera, however, referred to the struggles rent-controlled tenants face after eviction, saying the law is needed to assist tenants with relocation costs and significant rent increases.

“The district court's decision is contrary to cases interpreting the U.S. Constitution,” Herrera said in a statement. “San Francisco is facing a housing affordability crisis that's historically unprecedented, and our tenant relocation law serves a legitimate and lawful public purpose in helping tenants to adjust to the loss of rent control and mitigating the harms of displacement.”

In response to the appeal, Pacific Legal Foundation attorney J. David Breemer, the lead attorney in the challenge to the ordinance, said it is disappointing that city officials continue efforts “to defend the indefensible.” “(Lead clients Dan and Maria Levin) and Pacific Legal Foundation would prefer that the city spend its energy coming up with solutions to the affordable housing crisis that are constitutional and just,” said Breemer, adding that the foundation is prepared to go to the U.S. Supreme Court to fight the legislation.

But Herrera said defending the tenant relocation law has high stakes for more than just tenants, with consequences that could be dire for laws protecting land use and the environment if the judge's decision stands.

Bay Area NewsDennis HerreraEllis Actevictions

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

San Francisco Sheriff candidate Paul Miyamoto in a meeting with the Examiner editorial board on Thursday, Sept. 19, 2019. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
New shelter-in-place order gives tenants a temporary reprieve from eviction

Sheriff’s Department resumed regular enforcement this week for the first time since March

Under stay-at-home orders effective today in San Francisco, outdoor dining is not allowed, and there are new limits regarding the number of people that can be indoors at essential businesses. <ins> (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)</ins>
Bay Area counties to shut down outdoor dining, non-essential businesses

Regional stay-at-home order to take effect Sunday, sooner than statewide order announced Thursday

Former Golden State Warriors’ Kevin Durant received his 2017-18 Championship ring at Oracle Arena in Oakland on Oct. 16, 2018. Durant, now playing with the Brooklyn Nets, will play against his former team at Chase Center in February. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Kevin Durant to face former teammates at Chase Center in February

Schedule released Friday calls for Warriors to play Christmas and New Year’s Day games

San Francisco 49ers running back Raheem Mostert’s (31) return from injury last week was key for the team’s offense. <ins>(Chris Victorio/Special to S.F. Examiner)</ins>
49ers fighting for final NFC wild-card spot in Monday’s game against the Bills

Bills at 49ers When: Monday, 5:15 p.m. Where: State Farm Stadium, Glendale,… Continue reading

The Smashing Pumpkins’ 2020 recording is the 20-song “CYR.” (Courtesy photo)
Billy Corgan continues to confound expectations

Smashing Pumpkins release retro-sounding ‘CYR’

Most Read