Chief ‘disappointed’ firefighter in brawl was suspended, not fired

Fire Chief Joanne Hayes-White said she was “disappointed” that a firefighter who punched another in a firehouse brawl that was covered up received a 120-day suspension instead of getting fired.

The San Francisco Fire Commission voted Monday to suspend Bela Carreira, a five-year department veteran, for punching Joel Soto, who was in his first, probationary year, in an on-duty brawl. The San Francisco Fire Commission stopped short of accepting Chief Joanne Hayes-White’s recommendation to fire Carreira because it found that Soto had attacked Carreira first.

In June, The Examiner reported that some of the firefighters of Station 32 in Bernal Heights covered up the May 20 fight. Acting Lt. Tom Masterson, who was in charge of the station the night of the fight and allegedly coordinated the cover-up, resigned, as he faced a 90-day suspension.

“It is a stiff penalty,” Hayes-White said of the 120-day suspension. “I don't recall one in recent history being this long, but it wasn’t what I was recommending or seeking.” She said the suspension was “discouraging” because workplace violence should not be tolerated.

Soto, who is on probationary status, will lose his job, sources said. Hayes-White did not confirm or deny that because the disciplinary process is still ongoing.

Three other firefighters and paramedics on duty the night of the fight received suspensions of between eight and nine days for their parts in the cover-up. The chief has the power to suspend department members up to 10 days without bringing the matter before the commission.

Soto, who suffered a cut lip and broken cheek after Carreira hit him, claimed that Carreira had attacked him after an argument that continued throughout the 12-hour shift. The argument started when Carreira told Soto that it was impolite to speak Spanish in the firehouse, Soto’s lawyer, William McDevitt, said.

After two deadlocked votes, the four voting commission members decided to retain Carreira in the department. They suspended him for 90 days for the violent incident and 30 days for the cover-up attempt.

Commissioners Stephen Nakajo, George Lau and President Paul Conroy voted in favor of the suspension. Commissioner Victor Makras voted against it.

“A suspension isn’t enough because violence in the workplace is 100 percent unacceptable,” Makras said Friday. He said Soto and Carreira shared equal responsibility for the fight, regardless of who started it or who was injured.

“What made me believe he [Carreira] should not be terminated is that the evidence showed that he did not initiate the physical aggression,” Conroy said Friday. “I believe it occurred very quickly and I don’t believe you take someone’s job away for that.”

Stephen Nakajo, who changed his vote from termination to the 120-day suspension, could not be reached for comment.

amartin@examiner.com

Bay Area NewsLocal

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

Those who stick around San Francisco on long holiday weekends can enjoy a slower pace, uncrowded streets and beloved institutions like cable cars. <ins>(Kevin Hume/S.F. Examiner)</ins>
These empty San Francisco streets: A holiday dream

We’re here because we can be, and because we have nowhere else to be

It’s disheartening to see that Bill Graham Civic’s marquee isn’t announcing upcoming concerts. (Screenshot/Bill Graham Civic Twitter)
A cruise through The City with the ghosts of rides past

I take my time and don’t even mind the occasional traffic jams

A ban on smoking or vaping in multi-unit buildings has drawn opposition from cannabis advocates, who say it would leave users with no legal place to consume a legal substance. (Shutterstock)
Cannabis group slams Yee’s proposed apartment smoking ban as ‘classist’

Legislation would impose fines of $1,000 a day on repeat violators

The most dangerous behaviors by drivers include failing to yield right-of-way at crosswalks, unsafe speeding and failing to stop at red lights or stop signs. <ins>(Ekevara Kitpowsong/Special to S.F. Examiner)</ins>
Hetch Hetchy in Yosemite, which supplies water to San Francisco, is among the concerns of the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, which is undergoing a change of leadership. <ins>(Courtesy SFPUC)</ins>
Changes in leadership at SFPUC spark concern, hope for future water policy

Will agency’s new commissioner continue to support Big Ag?

Most Read