Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell walks to the Senate chamber for a procedural vote to move forward with voting on the Republican proposed tax reform bill on Friday in Washington, D.C. (Alex Edelman/CNP/Sipa USA/TNS)

With Senate tax bill passed, deal-making with the House to begin

WASHINGTON — State and local tax breaks, the deficit, income tax brackets and drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge are among the potential flashpoints as congressional Republicans push to pass a tax bill by the end of the month.

While it’s widely expected that tax legislation will eventually pass the House and Senate before Congress leave Washington for the holidays, tense negotiations are ahead.

The Senate passed its version of the tax package early Saturday, 51-49. The House approved its plan last month.

Members of a joint congressional committee will now meet to resolve those differences, conflicts that pit all sorts of special interests against one another. But Republicans are so eager to pass a tax bill — and claim a so-far elusive big win in President Donald Trump’s first year — that compromise is not expected to be too difficult.

There are real differences, but they’re not the differences that as you get into a room and roll up your sleeves that can’t be overcome.” said Rep. Mark Meadows, who is chairman of the House’s Freedom Caucus, a group of about three dozen hardcore conservatives.

The political stakes are just too high to fail, Republicans said.

“I truly think it will be the most important thing we do in this Congress,” said Sen. Thom Tillis. “It may be the most impactful thing Republicans do over the next decade.”

Still, there are several significant differences between the House and Senate bills to overcome, particularly in the Senate with its narrow margin for error. Republicans control 52 of the 100 seats. Since all 46 Democrats and two independents are expected to oppose the tax bill, the Republicans can afford to lose only three Senate votes.

The major issues are:

State and local taxes

The Senate bill would preserve some state and local tax deductions, a change from Senate Republicans’ initial proposal. Lawmakers agreed to allow taxpayers to deduct up to $10,000 of their state and local property taxes on their federal
returns, echoing a compromise included in the House bill that passed last month.

The Senate version, though, may be problematic for Republicans in the House.

Thirteen Republicans voted against the House legislation in November, virtually all of them from New York, New Jersey and California — high-cost, high-tax states that would be among the biggest losers if state and local tax deductions for property, income and sales taxes are eliminated.

Some other California Republicans said they voted to advance the House bill last month despite misgivings.

Those Californians are now pushing for a final bill to include more of the state and local write-offs that disproportionately benefit their constituents.

Conservatives balk at the Senate change. Heritage Action for America, the advocacy arm of the conservative Heritage Foundation, said in a memo that “Senate Republicans were wise to eliminate all state and local tax … deductions in the Finance Committee’s tax reform proposal so that they could use the savings to lower tax rates across the board.”

The Senate bill would maintain the mortgage interest deduction on newly purchased properties, capped at the first $1 million. California and other states with high home prices
prefer that approach to the House bill, which would lower the cap to $500,000.

Tax brackets

Lawmakers hoped to cut the number of tax brackets in half as part of their initial goal to make the tax code so simple taxpayers would be able to file their tax returns on postcards. That turned out to be difficult to do, but the House proposal goes further in meeting the goal.

The House has proposed four tax brackets: 12 percent, 25 percent, 35 percent and the current top rate of 39.6 percent.

The Senate would keep the current seven-bracket system, but lower the rates to 10 percent, 12 percent, 22.5 percent, 25 percent, 32.5 percent, 35 percent and a lower top rate of 38.5 percent.

Arctic refuge

The Senate bill includes a provision that could allow oil and gas exploration in Alaska’s Arctic National Wildlife Refuge — a concession considered important to winning the support of Sen. Lisa Murkowski.

Twelve House Republicans, however, including Rep. Carlos Curbelo, a member of the House
Ways and Means Committee, told Republican leaders that they oppose such drilling.

“For decades, Congress has voted to prohibit oil and gas development in the refuge, with the overwhelming support of the American public,” the 12 wrote in a letter to House Speaker Paul Ryan and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell “Support for this protection remains strong today.”

One-year delay

Reflecting Trump’s top priority, both bills would drop the top corporate rate from 35 percent to 20 percent, but the Senate bill would do so in 2019, a year later than the House version proposes. The change would reduce the cost of the tax package and meet Senate budgetary rules, but House conservatives said it’s a mistake.

Corporate tax rate

The House bill would set the corporate tax rate at 20 percent, a smaller cut than Trump sought but an acknowledgment that a lower rate would blow a big hole in the federal deficit.

Several Senate proposals sought to raise a new corporate rate, but House conservatives signaled that 20 percent is nonnegotiable.

Health care mandate

The Senate bill would repeal the requirement in the 2010 Affordable Care Act that most people pay a penalty if they don’t purchase health insurance.

The provision isn’t in the House bill, but is popular among House conservatives. Yet those same conservatives are opposed to health care provisions that would be considered as a result of including
the repeal which might be necessary to delivering critical votes in the Senate.

Sen. Susan Collins said she expects legislation that would reinstate cost-sharing payments to insurance companies to pass before the tax bill is complete. The provision, authored by Sens. Lamar Alexander and Patty Murray would help lower health insurance premiums, she said.

House conservatives suggested that would be difficult to accept.

“I don’t think any of that flies,” said Rep. Jim Jordan, who likened the insurance provision to a bailout for the insurance industry.


Fiscal conservatives who had long opposed legislation that threatens to significantly increase the deficit have largely held their nose and embraced the tax package, saying they are willing to tolerate short-term debt to stimulate the economy.

Republican leaders hoped that a “dynamic scoring” of the tax bill by the Joint Committee on Taxation would be optimistic that
lower taxes would result in economic growth.

The analysis Thursday, however, showed that the bill would still cost $1 trillion, even after accounting for growth. Republicans questioned the accuracy of the committee’s projections.


If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at

Just Posted

BART Ambassadors are being called on to assist riders in social situations that don’t require police force. <ins>(Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)</ins>
BART formalizes ambassador program, prepares to hire more crisis intervention specialists

Public safety and police reform are key elements in campaigns of Board members Dufty and Simon

School board members Gabriela Lopez (left) and Alison Collins (right) say they have been the subject of frequent hateful, racist and sexist attacks during their time on the school board. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F Examiner)
Angered by Lowell decision, SFUSD grad targets school board members with violent imagery

Facebook page depicts two women of color on board with swastikas and x-marks on their faces

Supervisor Sandra Lee Fewer, a former school board member, said it was ‘ridiculous’ that the school district did not yet have a plan to reopen. <ins>(Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)</ins>
Supervisors demand SFUSD set a timeline for reopening

Pressure grows on district to resume in-person learning as The City’s COVID-19 case count goes down

“Tenet,” the new Christopher Nolan film starring John David Washington, is showing at the drive-in in Concord. (Courtesy Warner Bros.)
Drive-ins are popping up all over the Bay Area

There are pandemic-era options for movie lovers who want to watch outdoors

The San Francisco International Arts Festival will present performances this weekend outdoors at Fort Mason, including on the Parade Ground, Eucalyptus Grove and Black Point Battery. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
SF International Arts Festival wins health department approval for weekend performances

Rules allow no more than 50 people at outdoor Fort Mason performances

Most Read