(Octavio Jones/Tampa Bay Times/TNS)

(Octavio Jones/Tampa Bay Times/TNS)

Trump defies California senators with 9th Circuit judge nominations

WASHINGTON _ After months of negotiations and delays, the White House is moving to fill California’s three vacancies on the influential 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals _ over the strenuous objections of the state’s two Democratic senators.

White House officials had been negotiating with Sens. Dianne Feinstein and Kamala Harris, both of whom sit on the Senate Judiciary Committee, earlier in the year about filling these and other federal court vacancies in the state. But that dialogue collapsed this past summer, Senate aides said.

On Wednesday night, the Trump administration announced it was nominating three attorneys to the 9th Circuit, the largest and busiest federal appeals court in the country. Among the thorny issues the court has tackled or could decide on are the legality of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, program for undocumented young people brought to the country as children, the president’s travel ban on people from several Muslim-majority countries, and a lawsuit challenging the White House’s attempts to withhold federal funds from sanctuary cities.

The White House also announced nominees for three district court vacancies in California on Wednesday.

President Donald Trump’s nominees for the appeals court _ litigators Daniel Collins and Kenneth Lee and Assistant United States Attorney Patrick Bumatay _ are all based in Southern California, are prominent members of the conservative Federalist Society, and have worked for Republican administrations. None of the three were approved by Feinstein or Harris via a process known as a “blue slip,” the senators’ offices confirmed Thursday.

“Last night the White House moved forward without consulting me, picking controversial candidates from its initial list and another individual with no judicial experience who had not previously been suggested,” Feinstein said in a statement.

“Instead of working with our office to identify consensus nominees for the 9th Circuit, the White House continues to try to pack the courts with partisan judges who will blindly support the president’s agenda, instead of acting as an independent check on this administration,” Lily Adams, Harris’ communications director, said in a statement.

Traditionally, presidents have deferred to home-state senators when nominating federal judges, agreeing not to nominate people unless those senators returned their blue slip in support of the prospective judge.

Trump and Senate Republicans, however, have done away with that custom, angering Democrats as they pushed forward controversial nominees for appeals court posts in Ohio, Minnesota and Wisconsin.

As the leading Democrat on the Judiciary Committee, Feinstein has more clout than the average Senate Democrat. And the White House and Senate Republicans were initially careful to engage her. Last spring, White House sent Feinstein and Harris’ offices a list of possible nominees to fill vacancies left by the retirements of two 9th Circuit judges and the death of a third. That list reportedly included Lee and Collins.

According to legal experts McClatchy spoke to at the time, the two men and other names on the list were all respected attorneys. “By and large, (the White House’s candidates) have the kind of conventional legal credentials that you would be looking for,” said judiciary expert Russell Wheeler, a visiting fellow at the Brookings Institution, a centrist D.C. think tank.

But in her statement, Feinstein said she and Harris have significant concerns about both Lee and Collins. “I met with (White House Counsel) Don McGahn on June 27 to discuss the vacancies and explained that Sen. Harris and I strongly opposed Daniel Collins,” the senator said. “I also told him Kenneth Lee had problems because he failed to disclose to our judicial selection committees controversial writings on voting rights and affirmative action.”

Another issue for Democrats: the nominees’ age. The judgeships are lifetime appointments. Bumatay, Collins and Lee are all in their 40s and 50s _ which means they could potentially remain on the 9th Circuit Court for decades. Democrats preferred older nominees.

The senators responded in May with their own proposed picks: U.S. District Court Judge Lucy Koh, whom President Barack Obama nominated for the 9th Circuit in 2016; U.S. District Court Judge Andrew Guilford; and Boris Feldman, a partner at Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Rosati in Palo Alto, Calif. Guilford and Feldman have GOP credentials, and both are in their 60s.

On Oct. 5, Feinstein’s office sent a letter to McGahn acknowledging the White House had rejected the senator’s three proposed picks, and offered a compromise: Koh from the Democrats’ list, Judge James Rogan, a former Republican congressman and state legislator, from the White House list, and one other. Feinstein raised the possibility of “Daniel Collins or another nominee from one of our two lists” for the third vacancy.

“I hope to work with you to resolve this matter as soon as possible,” California’s senior senator wrote.

The White House did not take her up on that offer.

-By Emily Cadei and Kate Irby, McClatchy Washington Bureau

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

City Administrator Naomi Kelly said Wednesday that the allegations against her husband were “based on the word of a liar.” (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
City Administrator Naomi Kelly takes leave after feds charge husband

High-ranking official under scrutiny over 2016 China trip

Lyft, owner of the Bay Wheels bikeshare program, stands to receive more than $300,000 in a legal settlement with The City. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
Supervisors to weigh $330,000 settlement with Lyft over bikeshare dispute

If approved, deal would resolve an 18-month long legal battle over San Francisco’s e-bike market

The J Church train could begin running again later this month on at least part of its surface route. (Mira Laing/Special to S.F. Examiner)
First Muni trains will return to service Dec. 19

Three additional bus routes coming back online in January

Smoking cannabis. (Shutterstock)
Supes ban tobacco smoking in apartments but exempt cannabis

San Francisco banned smoking and vaping of tobacco in apartments Tuesday night,… Continue reading

Dr. Grant Colfax and Mayor London Breed said new restrictions could come this week due to rising COVID-19 cases.<ins> (Examiner screenshot)</ins>
Breed: ‘More restrictive action’ needed to slow spread of COVID-19

San Francisco officials said Tuesday tougher restrictions will soon be imposed to… Continue reading

Most Read