Supreme Court may limit partisan gerrymanders

 

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court heard a strong argument Tuesday for reining in partisan gerrymandering — at least if it’s extreme enough to allow one party’s politicians to keep themselves in power for a decade.

Better yet for the groups challenging gerrymanders, Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, who likely holds the swing vote on the issue, seemed open to ruling that extreme gerrymanders are unconstitutional.

“Politicians are never going to fix gerrymandering. You are the only institution in the United States that can solve this problem,” Paul Smith, an attorney for Wisconsin Democrats, who brought the current case, told the justices.

Kennedy asked a lawyer for Wisconsin’s Republicans whether it would be constitutional for the state to adopt a law that the election map will be drawn to “favor party X over party Y.”

Attorney Erin Murphy hesitated, noting that in this case, Republicans did not publicly proclaim that they were drawing a statewide map to ensure the GOP would maintain a solid majority, even though that was the effect of the district lines they created.

Kennedy was undeterred. “I’d like an answer to my question,” he said.

By the time the hourlong argument ended, it was clear that Kennedy believes the Constitution would prevent one party from writing a law designed to keep itself in power for a decade. What was unclear is whether he was convinced that the Republicans in Wisconsin had in effect done that when they went behind closed doors and drew legislative boundaries after the last Census.

The district lines the Republican-controlled legislature adopted ensured the GOP would have a 60-vote supermajority in the state’s Assembly, the lower house of its Legislature, even if a majority of voters statewide voted for Democrats, as they did in subsequent elections.

By contrast to Kennedy, Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. made clear he was opposed to the court taking on the issue of partisan gerrymandering based on what he called “sociological gobbledygook.” He was referring to statistical studies that characterize the Wisconsin electoral map as highly unusual.

If the court declares the Wisconsin map unconstitutional, the justices in years to come will have to decide on a series of highly political disputes, he said.

The case heard Tuesday, Gill v. Whitford, is a once-in-a-decade challenge to partisan gerrymandering, a process that since 2010 has allowed Republicans to control power in at least half a dozen states where the voters are closely divided.

Wisconsin provides a textbook example. The GOP redistricting plan succeeded in preserving Republican control of the legislature despite their losing a majority of voters statewide. Federal judges ruled that the Wisconsin Republicans had gone too far and had unfairly “entrenched” themselves in power.

The high court, however, has never before struck down a state’s election districts simply because they were unfairly partisan.

If Kennedy and four other justices say Wisconsin went too far, the outcome could reach far beyond that state to potentially reshape the U.S. House of Representatives.

The justices will hand down a decision in the case later in the court’s term.

US

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

San Francisco Giants pitcher Anthony DeSclafani (26) starts against the Colorado Rockies at Oracle Park on April 11, 2021 in San Francisco, California. (Photography by Chris Victorio | Special to the S.F. Examiner).
Giants finish sweep of Rockies behind DeSclafani’s scoreless outing

Even with fans back at Oracle Park, San Francisco Giants pitchers have… Continue reading

Kindergarten teacher Chris Johnson in his classroom at Bryant Elementary School ahead of the school’s reopening on Friday, April 9, 2021. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
SFUSD students are going back to the classroom

After more than a year of distance learning, city schools begin reopening on Monday

Keith Zwölfer, director of education for SFFILM, stays busy connecting filmmakers and studios with public, private and home schools<ins>.</ins><ins> (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner) </ins>
Streamlined SF film festival focuses on family features

In the early days of the San Francisco International Film Festival, the… Continue reading

“Gay Passover,” a fun Haggadah, includes some cocktail recipes. <ins>(Courtesy Saul Sugarman)</ins>
A Passover journey toward something different

It was nice to see my family, and I look forward to reconnecting with friends

Oakland A’s left fielder Tony Kemp fielded a fly but missed the catch in the April 5 game against the Los Angeles Dodgers at the Oakland Coliseum. <ins>(Chris Victorio/Special to S.F. Examiner)</ins>
Bay Area sports for week of April 11, 2021

A look at the upcoming major Bay Area sports events (schedules subject… Continue reading

Most Read