Media Matters scoffs at claim that insurance companies save lives

 

President Obama and Speaker Pelosi are undoubtedly better at providing people with the care they need than insurance companies, according to the hyperbolic headline of this Media Matters blogpost: “Worst. Talking point. Ever.”

There, they highlight a quote by the Cato Institute's Michael Cannon, in which he says: “Insurance companies save more lives in a single day than President Obama or Nancy Pelosi will save in their entire lifetimes.” The video is below.

< param name='allowscriptaccess' value='always'>

 

What's wrong here? Cannon's point that insurance companies attempt to maximize care for the maximum amount of people possible under budgetary constraints is a fact, not an opinion. The claim that government-run health care will be more responsive to people ignores that it will be subject to political decision-making, government waste, and unnatural price controls.

Also, if we're going to split hairs about it, insurance companies cannot wage war. Wacky result: Obama kills more people than insurance companies. Should he be trusted with your health care? (Take that straw man!)

Just Posted

SF’s newest subway may emerge on the West Side

San Francisco’s sleepy West Side — from the Richmond District to Parkmerced… Continue reading

Treasure Island residents could win new displacement protections

Supervisor working to give all current residents a chance to move into new development

Bay Bridge fire blocks Friday night traffic

UPDATE 11:35 p.m.: The fire is out, Caltrans is reporting. Three of… Continue reading

SF lawmaker proposes car-free Tenderloin streets

Proposal comes after a spate of traffic deaths in the neighborhood.

SF to open seventh job center in ‘overlooked’ neighborhoods

Oceanview, Merced Heights, Ingleside area has unemployment rates much higher than the city average

Most Read