Group challenges health law as unconstitutional

The Sacramento-based Pacific Legal Foundation this week will take another step in its challenge to President Barack Obama's health care law, claiming it imposes new taxes unconstitutionally.

The foundation, which advocates for limited government, is scheduled to make oral arguments Thursday in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. A district court ruled last year against the foundation, which filed the case on behalf of Iraq war veteran and Washington state small business owner Matt Sissel.

Foundation attorney Timothy Sandefur said during a news conference Monday that the Affordable Care Act should be considered unconstitutional because it violated the Constitution's origination clause, which requires tax bills to start in the House as a way to keep taxing authority closer to the people.

He said Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid had taken a House measure to help veterans buy homes, gutted it and transformed it into the Affordable Care Act legislation, which requires most Americans to carry health insurance and prohibits insurers from turning away the sick. After a long debate, the bill barely passed a divided Congress, with no Republican support.

“We say completely gutting the entire contents of a bill and replacing it with an entirely different bill is not an amendment; that's just subterfuge,” Sandefur told reporters outside the state Capitol.

In June 2012, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the crux of the health care law, ruling that the penalties to enforce it are a tax Congress is authorized to levy. About 8 million people had signed up for an individual policy on the newly created online marketplaces through the April 15 enrollment deadline.

Another 4.8 million lower-income people gained coverage through an expansion of Medicaid, which the Supreme Court ruled was optional for the states.

Sandefur acknowledged that the foundation is arguing a procedural rule after the nation's highest court made its decision, but he said the court should clarify the role of the Senate and the House in tax bills.

“If the people of the United States want the Affordable Care Act, then there's no reason why Congress can't go back and repass this thing the correct way,” he said.

Messages left for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the U.S. Department of Justice were not immediately returned Monday.CaliforniaCalifornia NewsCovered Californiahealthcare

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at

Just Posted

Breed: SF receives 3.6K state access codes giving teachers vaccine priority

San Francisco has received its first vaccine priority access codes from the… Continue reading

Charles Joseph, who is represented by the San Francisco Public Defender’s office, is facing deportation to Fiji. <ins>(Courtesy photo)</ins>
Giving immigrants a second chance after incarceration

Legislation would allow some faced with deportation a chance to challenge their old convictions

The San Francisco Police Department released body camera footage of the alleged assault on Dacari Spiers. (Via SFPD Body Cam)
SF police officer to stand trial for assault over baton beating

A San Francisco police officer who prosecutors say unnecessarily beat a man… Continue reading

Mayor London Breed announced The City’s return to the red tier for COVID-19 precautions at Pier 39 on Tuesday<ins>, March 2, 2021</ins>. <ins>(Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)</ins>
San Francisco enters red COVID tier, indoor dining to resume

Museums and gyms can reopen with capacity limits

Cole Odin Berggren, community programs director and drum and DJ instructor at Blue Bear School of Music in The City, holds a JackTrip device, which he says has greatly improved students’ experience of making music online. (Kevin N. Hume/S.F. Examiner)
COVID-era musicians beginning to make connections

Software eliminates pesky delay plaguing most systems

Most Read