Few lasting lessons from NY-23

Whether they win or lose today's election, Republicans will argue in vain against a news media eager to portray the party as intolerant of moderates. But here is an apt analogy for helping liberal reporters overcome their myopia and understand what's really going on: What if today's race had been in Georgia, and Democratic party leaders there had chosen Zell Miller as their candidate in some smoke-filled back room? 

Mainstream, rank-and-file Democrats would rebel at having such a nominee — and rightly so. They would object that his issue positions are all conservative. They would argue that he had become the ally of Sean Hannity and conservative Republican leaders, and retains scarcely a trace of Democratic thinking. (Forget Zell Miller — just look at what they did to Sen. Joe Lieberman in Connecticut.) 

That's the real story of New York-23.  

Presumably, there is some series of questions to which one can attach the statement, “You might be a Republican if you answer 'yes' to any of the following.” Scozzafava is not your ordinary moderate — she checks none of the boxes. In other words, this story has less to do with big or small tents than it has to do with whether there can be any definition of what a Republican is. 

By the same token, despite a lot of conservative wishful thinking, even a Republican victory in New York tonight offers few lessons for next year's races. New York's unusual election law promotes robust third party activity. And in next year's races, the party rank-and-file will get to choose their candidates in party primaries in nearly all cases. A win by Conservative Party nominee Doug Hoffman does not usher in a new age of conservative rebellion, and more than a Democratic win proves conservative irrelevance.

Beltway ConfidentialUS

If you find our journalism valuable and relevant, please consider joining our Examiner membership program.
Find out more at www.sfexaminer.com/join/

Just Posted

Two new contractors charged with bribery in Nuru scandal

Two construction executives are facing federal bribery charges for allegedly giving former… Continue reading

S.F. museums to reopen to the public

Visitor capacity limited to 25 percent as safety measure

Small businesses in limbo as end of eviction moratorium nears

Many commercial tenants ‘teetering on the edge,’ unable to pay rent

Despite long run of ‘Spare the Air’ days, free transit remains a rarity

In response to weeks of unhealthy air quality caused by smoke from… Continue reading

City hopes to convert Granada Hotel to supportive housing

State grant could allow purchase of 232-unit Lower Nob Hill SRO

Most Read