School board candidate loses endorsements over transgender comments

Two major endorsers dropped their support for school board candidate Josephine Zhao this week following the revelation of comments she made in the Chinese language press in 2013 that a transgender bathroom law could lead to “rape” in schools.

Supervisor Catherine Stefani and supervisor candidate Christine Johnson pulled their endorsement for Zhao this week, who is running for the Board of Education this November.

Both face elections in November: Stefani for District 2, representing neighborhoods including the Marina and Pacific Heights neighborhoods, and Johnson for District 6, representing the South of Market and the Tenderloin neighborhoods.

Zhao gave her first apology for the remarks she made in 2013 just this week, which was reported exclusively by the San Francisco Examiner, and says she has since changed her views.

Though Stefani and Johnson each recognized that apology, they placed the well-being of the San Francisco Unified School District’s diverse student body first. Suicide rates are sadly, heart-breakingly high in the transgender community. One study by the Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center found 30 percent of trans youth reported at least one suicide attempt.

“Recent news stories on comments Josephine Zhao made about gender neutral bathrooms and our trans community are very troubling,” Stefani said in a statement.

“I endorsed Josephine because of her work for families in our community and her perspective as a mother, and I appreciate that she has apologized and has learned from her mistake. However, I strongly believe it is our responsibility to ensure that every child in our schools feels safe, comfortable and welcome. Therefore, I am withdrawing my endorsement of her campaign.”

Speaking on the phone Friday, Johnson denounced Zhao’s remarks.

“Seems like she’s put out a public statement, like she’s trying to address the issue, but I can’t abide anyone who dehumanizes others,” Johnson told me. “I think she has some more work to do.”

Zhao, for her part, took the endorsement drops in stride.

“That’s not a problem,” she said. “They’ve got to do what’s best for themselves and their campaigns.”

Zhao told me she had “misunderstood” the 2013 law, which allows transgender students to use the restroom of the gender they identify with.

“I did apologize for not understanding what the law truly was,” she said.

But when I asked her if she had apologized and clarified her remarks in an op-ed piece to the Chinese community, as she had done in the English press, Zhao became evasive.

“I don’t appreciate the line of questions, you’re putting me on interrogation,” Zhao said. “The line of questions are not friendly at all.”

Zhao still has two big backers: Mayor London Breed and State Senator Scott Wiener.

“I stand by my endorsement,” Breed said after a press conference Friday. “Sadly, people make mistakes and sometimes people they say things either in the wrong way, where it can be perceived in an unfortunate way, but I think Josephine Zhao is a good person.”

* * *

It’s not all controversy out there in politics land, as the Edwin M. Lee Asian Pacific Democratic Club had a fun time supporting the new movie Crazy Rich Asians, a romantic comedy starring the ever-amazing Constance Wu (seriously, watch Fresh Off the Boat if you haven’t yet, it’s a trip).
Don’t let the silly rom-com exterior fool you, though, as its a profound moment for the Asian-American community (and its allies) to see an all-Asian cast and Asian director for the first in a Hollywood flick since the Joy Luck Club — a whopping 25 years ago!

Monday night, the Ed Lee Club rented out part of the 1000 Van Ness AMC Theater to screen the film for its members. Mary Jung, a board member of the club, said it was a who’s-who of the local Asian political community: State Board of Equalization board member Fiona Ma, Assemblymember David Chiu, Public Defender Jeff Adachi, Assemblymember Phil Ting, Film Commissioner Claudine Cheng, and Arts Commissioner Lydia So attended, among others.

Ultimately they packed the house with more than 500 excited movie-goers.

Jung said the movie showcased Asian people of all stripes. “There was a funny guy, a serious guy, a business guy.”

“It just seemed like people that I knew,” Jung said. That is, except for one teeny-tiny detail, Jung said.

“These people,” she said, “had way too much money.”

Hollywood is escapism after all, isn’t it?

* * *

It’s the grunts that make political campaigns go round, and with so many serious political campaigns going on right now, sign-carrying worker bees are buzzing across The City. Enter Natalie Gee, an SF native and campaigner for District 10 supervisor candidate Shamann Walton, and Ryan McGilley, also an SF native who is campaigning for District 4 supervisor candidate Gordon Mar.

Both are “super busy” working on those political campaigns, Gee told me, and they rarely see each other. Maybe once a week she said. Except! — Tuesday night each of their candidates was up for endorsement at the Alice B. Toklas Club. “I was finding parking, I said oh hey, ‘That’s Ryan!’”

After the Alice meeting, they both went out for ramen.

“That one turned into a date night,” she said — Finally.

On Guard prints the news and raises hell each week. Email Fitz at, follow him on Twitter and Instagram @FitztheReporter, and Facebook at

Joe Fitzgerald Rodriguez
Published by
Joe Fitzgerald Rodriguez

Recent Posts

Oakland Athletics not scoreboard watching with chance to clinch at home

OAKLAND -- There was not a single television in the Oakland Athletics tuned to the Tampa Bay-Toronto game on Sunday…

57 mins ago

BART equipment failure fills Civic Center Station with smoke

Smoke from an equipment failure on a BART track prompted transit officials to temporarily close Civic Center Station on Saturday…

4 hours ago

RV life

David Samples lived in a rundown 1971 Chinook RV in the Bayview District for about six months before he sought…

12 hours ago

Oakland Athletics could clinch playoff berth at home as magic number drops to one

OAKLAND -- The Tampa Bay Rays had just fallen behind 3-1 to the Toronto Blue Jays, and in the Oakland…

13 hours ago

Questions remain as Treasurer’s Public Bank Task Force comes to a close

Seven months after convening the Municipal Public Bank Task Force and after, presumably, seven months of research, public bank advocates…

13 hours ago

Who’s in charge at Lake Merced?

Lake Merced is a recreational and natural wonder in the southwest corner of San Francisco. Rowers, dragon boat racers, golfers,…

13 hours ago