Say cheese! Monkey selfie case back in SF federal court for appeal

An animal rights group is appealing a ruling from a federal judge in San Francisco that an Indonesian monkey does not have legal rights to photographs he took of himself.

An attorney for People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) will ask the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit to review Wednesday the decision that a monkey is not the author of a selfie under the U.S. Copyright Act.

PETA is arguing that a 6-year-old crested macaque named Naruto is the copyright owner of selfies taken in 2011.

The intelligent monkey intended to press the camera shutter while making different facial expressions at the lens, making him the author, the group said. But the photographer who owned the camera Naruto used later published the images.

“When science and technology advance, the law adapts,” PETA attorney Jeffrey Kerr said in a statement. “There is nothing in the Copyright Act limiting ownership based on species, and PETA is asking for an interpretation of the act that acknowledges today’s scientific consensus that macaque monkeys can create an original work.”

U.S. District Judge William Orrick dismissed the case in January 2016, citing a previous court decision that said a law does not apply to animals unless it “plainly” says “animal” rather than “persons” or “human beings.”

“The Copyright Act does not ‘plainly’ extend the concept of authorship or statutory standing to animals,” Orrick wrote in his decision. “To the contrary, there is no mention of animals anywhere in the act.”

Michael Barba
Published by
Michael Barba

Recent Posts

A few words about critters with English Beat’s Dave Wakeling

At 61, San Fernando-Valley-based Brit Dave Wakeling knows how surreal it sounds to have not one, but two, viable versions…

2 hours ago

Rejected scooter company files appeal, calls SF permit process ‘secret’ and ‘unlawful’

An e-scooter company rejected from San Francisco’s shared scooter pilot program has filed an appeal, alleging The City’s application criteria…

3 hours ago

Drivers to pay Treasure Island toll in both directions starting in 2021

Starting in 2021, drivers travelling to or from Treasure Island will be forced to pay a toll in addition to…

3 hours ago

1 dead, 1 arrested in SoMa hit and run

A 65-year-old man was struck and killed by a vehicle in a hit-and-run in San Francisco's South of Market neighborhood…

7 hours ago

If you want to address climate change, clean up the air

Like climate change itself, recent environmental news from throughout the country can feel overwhelming and scary. As leaders from around…

15 hours ago

Transportation justice requires housing justice, and vice versa

Why should transportation advocates support ballot measures put forth by housing activists? And why should housing activists defend a gas…

15 hours ago