Proposition T would curtail lobbyist influence over City Hall

Proposition T aims to reduce the power of lobbyists over City Hall, and as November nears it faces little opposition to do so.

Proposed by the San Francisco Ethics Commission for this November’s ballot in a 4-0 vote, Prop. T would task lobbyists with identifying who in city government they intend to contact in the near future — and then bar lobbyists from making any gifts, including for travel, to those city officers and their families within 90 days of that activity.

Friends of Ethics member Larry Bush said lobbyists carry undue influence over City Hall.

“You see lobbyists giving unspecified amounts of money who carry influence with the mayor,” Bush told the San Francisco Examiner in an editorial board meeting.

Notably, Ethics Commission records show Mayor Ed Lee was gifted a $6,400 trip to Brazil in March this year, by the San Francisco Center for Economic Development. A group called the Jewish Community Relations Council gifted Lee a $10,730 trip to Israel in April.

San Francisco Treasurer Jose Cisneros has at least 14 trips paid for by private gifts reported to the Ethics Commission, between the beginning of 2015 to present date, the largest number on file for that time period.

Perhaps more pernicious is the issue of “bundling,” Bush said, which Prop. T would also ban.

Many lobbyists collect checks from their clients to then donate in a group to a politician they wish to influence, Bush said, which is called bundling.

“It exaggerates the influence of those seeking approvals” for government contracts, he said. Last election for instance, he said, District 3 supervisor candidate Julie Christensen and sheriff candidate Vicki Hennessy garnered the most “bundled” contributions — often from lobbyists who were known allies of the mayor, who also backed both candidates.

There are some carve-outs in Prop. T.

Nonprofits, for instance, would be allowed to provide gifts of food or refreshment up to $25 for all attendees at a public event, which was an exception crafted after outreach to the community, said SF Ethics Commission Executive Director LeeAnn Pelham.

And the measure only targets lobbyists who have identified specific city officials they intend to lobby. Paul Renne, Ethics Commission chair, told the Examiner that a more broad ban of gifts may not hold up in court, according to commission research.

And, Pelham said, it does not bar lobbyists from donating to independent expenditure committees, though it does bar them from donating to ballot committees held by specific candidates.

One common concern of many ballot-box laws is they require another ballot to amend. Prop. T has language that allows the Ethics Commission or Board of Supervisors to amend the law with a supermajority vote, Renne said.

Reducing lobbyist influence on government is important, Bush said, because, “I feel for a lot of people in San Francisco, it creates a stronger sense that people’s voices matter.”

Joe Fitzgerald Rodriguez
Published by
Joe Fitzgerald Rodriguez

Recent Posts

SF police find more combustible materials at home of SoMa explosion suspect

After an explosion blew out the windows of a building in South of Market on Sunday, police searched the home…

51 mins ago

Woman who fell to her death in Muni’s Van Ness Station identified

A woman who fell to her death on the tracks of Muni’s Van Ness Station Monday night has been identified…

1 hour ago

UPDATE: Civic Center BART and Muni station reopens after flooding

UPDATE 3:34 p.m.: BART and the San Francisco Municipal Transporation Agency have reopened Civic Center station in time for the…

2 hours ago

SFUSD employee found dead in San Francisco Bay

A 67-year-old woman who was found dead in the San Francisco Bay early Tuesday morning has been identified as a…

3 hours ago

Woman arrested after found soaking wet on Half Moon Bay beach with infant

HALF MOON BAY - A 36-year-old woman was arrested on suspicion of attempted murder Tuesday after San Mateo County sheriff's…

3 hours ago

Suspect identified in murder-suicide of North Beach music staple

The suspect in the murder-suicide of a man known for running a 1990s underground music venue in North Beach has…

5 hours ago