Police could get increased power to disperse abortion clinic protesters

A proposed amendment to The City’s Police Code could allow officers to respond more quickly to complaints of harassment and intimidation of clients at a Mission District Planned Parenthood clinic that for years has been a frequent target for anti-abortion protesters.

Current law requires police officers to provide a written warning before ordering protesters to disperse while also ensuring access to the reproductive health care facility.

The amendment, proposed by Supervisor Hillary Ronen, would allow police officers to order protesters who are in violation of city law prohibiting harassment within a 25-foot buffer zone around the Mission Street clinic to disperse after just a verbal warning.

The Board of Supervisors’ Public and Neighborhood Safety Committee is expected to vote on the change today, and if it is approved it will move before the full board on Sept. 18.

Historically, “buffer zone” laws prohibited any kind of first amendment activity — including picketing — from taking place within a certain distance of abortion providers. In San Francisco, 2013 legislation introduced by then-supervisor David Campos expanded that zone from 8 feet to 25 feet.

The following year, however, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down Massachusetts’ 35-foot buffer zone around reproductive health clinics offering abortion services — a decision that trickled down to San Francisco.

“The City Attorney basically told us that our law was no longer valid. So, we amended the law to make it illegal to follow or harass a [person] within the 25-foot buffer zone,” said Ronen, who served as a legislative aide to Campos before replacing him as supervisor. “That law has been on books ever since it passed.”

But the anti-harassment law has proven difficult to enforce for police officers, whose hands are tied by bureaucratic processes balancing protections for the clinic’s clients against the protesters’ right to free speech.

The requirement to issue written warnings prevents officers from taking immediate enforcement actions in cases in which clients report harassment, and is also unique to police guidelines governing enforcement at abortion clinics.

“Usually in other First Amendment activities, say you have a climate protest, if these folks are blocking the street or chained together at Fourth or Market streets, a verbal warning is enough to issue a dispersal order. And if the order is not followed there can be an arrest,” said Ingleside Police Station Captain Jack Hart. “This particular section has an added requirement that a written notice is needed.”

According to Ronen, this requirement is “slowing [police] down.”

“It was making the enforcement of the law more difficult and less nimble and allowed protesters to continue to harass women within the buffer zone,” Ronen said.

Ronen said complaints increased after yellow paint marking the buffer zone on the sidewalk in front of the clinic and street signage educating protesters of the law were removed during recent streetscaping on Valencia Street. The increase also coincided with the recent change in presidential administration.

“We suspect these people are emboldened by President Trump and an increasingly anti-choice Supreme Court. It’s getting more extreme and scary and the protests are getting larger,” Ronen said. “We decided, in addition to repainting the zone and [replacing] the signage, we would change law so that police have an effective tool.”


Laura Waxmann
Published by
Laura Waxmann

Recent Posts

Klay Thompson’s late flurry, Kevin Durant triple-double not enough as Golden State Warriors fall in overtime to Los Angeles Clippers

By Jeffrey Dransfeldt Special to S.F. Examiner LOS ANGELES — Typically, a Klay Thompson second half explosion is a positive…

8 hours ago

Bedroom producer G FLIP hits with ‘About You’

In January 2017, Melbourne, Australia native Georgia Flipo’s mother and friends thought she was kidding when she said she would…

9 hours ago

Paradise High School football brought to tears by San Francisco 49ers invitation to Monday Night Football

SANTA CLARA, Calif. — On nearly a three-and-a-half hour bus ride en route to Levi’s Stadium in Santa Clara, students…

10 hours ago

SF to spend $4M to rebuild ‘burned to the ground’ Golden Gate Park clubhouse

After a popular Golden Gate Park clubhouse was burned down, San Francisco plans to rebuild it for $4 million. Under…

11 hours ago

Jordan Ratinho rains threes as USF Dons basketball easily dispatches Sonoma State

When Charles Minlend went down with a torn right labrum in June of 2017, University of San Francisco head men's…

12 hours ago

Death toll in Butte County fire at 42, making it worst in state history

The death toll from the Camp fire in the Northern California town of Paradise jumped to 42 Monday, making the…

14 hours ago