Park Service puts proposed GGNRA dog rules on hold

Under pressure from members of Congress and scrambling to respond to a lawsuit filed by dog owners, the National Park Service today said it would postpone the finalization of controversial dog management rules in the Golden Gate National Recreation Area.

Park service officials said they would put the rules on hold in response to a request from members of Congress to extend the waiting period for the Final Environmental Impact Statement, which was released on Dec. 8.

The rules, which would sharply reduce the areas within the GGNRA where dog owners can walk their pets on- or off-leash, were previously expected to be finalized as early as today.

Park service officials are also working to release and review records sought by dog owners in a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit that has revealed that a former employee used personal email during the decision-making process, according to a spokesman.

Since learning of the issue in December, the park service has recovered around 137 pages of emails from the former employee, in addition to the 260,000 pages of documents the agency says it has already released.

“The Park Service will conduct an independent inquiry into whether personal email was used in a manner that is not consistent with applicable laws and policies, and if so, whether its use affected the planning and rulemaking processes,” the agency said in a statement today.

Dog owners and recreation advocates filed the Freedom of Information Act lawsuit in April, alleging the park service was “slow walking” its response to the groups’ requests for data until after a public comment period.

The group has since posted records obtained in the lawsuit on a site called “Woofieleaks.com.” The records obtained show a biased, unfair decision-making process and destruction of records as well as the improper use of email, according to attorneys for the dog owners.

“The NPS dog management plan is plagued with legally significant procedural irregularities,” attorney Chris Carr said. “The deliberate destruction of public records, failing ‘recollections’ of computer passwords necessary to access years of documents, and the use of private emails by NPS personnel have revealed a fatally flawed, fundamentally unfair, and unlawful decision making process,” Carr said.

The agency and dog owners have been battling for years over proposed restrictions on dog walking within the 80,000-acre national recreation area, which spans Marin, San Francisco and San Mateo counties and includes popular dog walking areas such as Ocean Beach, Fort Funston, Crissy Field, Muir Beach and Rancho Corral de Tierra.

Park service officials have described the plan as “dog friendly,” and said it is intended to balance the needs of different park users, protect natural and cultural resources including wildlife, and increase public safety.

Dog owners groups have said that that they expect to sue to block the rules if and when they are finalized.

The park service is posting documents at on the proceedings here.

Bay City News
Share
Published by
Bay City News

Recent Posts

San Francisco Giants acquire versatile right-handed Rule 5 pick Connor Joe

The San Francisco Giants have made a minor personnel move, acquiring Rule 5 utility man Connor Joe from the Cincinnati…

9 mins ago

Homicide victim stabbed near Fisherman’s Wharf was local homeless man

Before he was killed, Brook Pettyjohn once jumped into the waters near Fisherman’s Wharf to retrieve a football he had…

2 hours ago

Golden Gate Bridge tolls set to climb

The Golden Gate Bridge, Highway and Transportation District is poised to raise Golden Gate Bridge tolls as high as they…

2 hours ago

SF Preps Baseball: Marin Catholic tosses another combined no-hitter

The Marin Catholic Wildcats remained undefeated with a 6-0 win over Novato on Wednesday, and got yet another combined no-hitter…

3 hours ago

Second polarizing figure separates from SF police union

A longtime leader of the San Francisco Police Officers Association has quit after the union severed ties with his predecessor…

5 hours ago

Klay Thompson stumping for USF’s Kyle Smith to get Washington State job

OAKLAND — The Golden State Warriors' Klay Thompson has filled out his NCAA March Madness bracket, and on Thursday, he…

6 hours ago