Labor-backed BART board candidate tells voters he doesn’t believe in right to strike

Jonathen Lyens, a rookie BART board candidate, was heard by multiple sources telling a room full of potential voters in San Francisco Sunday that he doesn’t believe public employees should have the right to strike.

While that’s not an uncommon view among some angry BART riders who felt inconvenienced by the 2013 BART worker strike, it is notable for a candidate — Lyens — who is endorsed by BART’s major unions, including SEIU 1021, ATU Local 1555 and AFSCME Local 3993.

Lyens addressed a room of about 40 potential voters at a “Back of the Ballot” election education party hosted by West Side politico Joel Engardio, who is also a San Francisco Examiner columnist. Candidates running in this November’s election for the BART Board of Directors spoke at the event, meant to educate voters about low-attention races, including Lyens, Melanie Nutter, and Janice Li, a staffer with the San Francisco Bicycle Coalition.

“He said he felt public employees should not strike, and included himself in that because he works for The City,” said Sally Stephens, a West Side voter who is also a columnist for the San Francisco Examiner.

Stephens attended the event and said she has no favored candidate in the race, yet. But, she said, “I’m pretty pro-union.”

Lyens made the statement while speaking to the entire room, Stephens said.

Though Lyens has also run for District 1 supervisor, he has in the past been regarded as a long-shot candidte. This time around, however, he is perceived by many as a front-of-the-pack candidate, especially considering his backing by BART’s major unions. Lyens is running on a platform of getting “back to basics,” he told the Examiner, including ensuring elevators and escalators work and basic rail service needs are met, because disability issues are especially pertinent to him as a member of the diasability community. Lyens is blind. He also emphasized a need for labor harmony.

Labor relations have been tense at BART for years, leading to the 2013 strike that snarled Bay Area transit for days and saw agency management run trains with untrained operator trainees to circumvent the strike, leading to the deaths of two workers.

Lyens also faces a crucial San Francisco Democratic Party endorsement vote Wednesday evening.

When asked to confirm his statements, Lyens apologized, but neither confirmed nor directly denied he made the statements.

“It was a misspeak,” he said. And characterized his statements, “if I failed to articulate clearly,” as “things that came out of my mouth not in the way they were in my head.”

That said, he emphasized that he was on a picket line with AFSCME six months ago, and that as a child of two air traffic controllers he supports labor’s right to strike.

“What I’m telling you is I believe one thousand percent in the right of workers to strike,” he said.

But, Stephens said, that’s not what Lyens said Sunday.

“He definitely said he didn’t think public employees, including BART employees, including himself, should be able to strike,” she said. “I’m confident I heard him say that.”

Gabriel Haaland, a political coordinator with SEIU 1021, said he still has confidence in Lyens. “Our union interviewed him three different times” and “I don’t think he believes that,” he said.

Though Lyens may have made a gaffe, he was not the only candidate to make a major reversal in position after Engardio’s inaugural Back of the Ballot party. Li, a candidate who has served on the late Mayor Ed Lee’s Transportation Task Force 2045, told the crowd she may not support BART replacing its fare gates for taller versions to curb fare evaders, which the San Francisco Chronicle reported may cost as much as $200 million.

After the event, she sent an email cementing her position in support of fare gates.

“I’m in support of replacing fare gates,” she wrote in the email. “It’s BART passengers that lose out the most when revenues are lost.”

Joe Fitzgerald Rodriguez
Published by
Joe Fitzgerald Rodriguez

Recent Posts

Flashy stunts, sketchy story in Cirque du Soleil’s ‘Volta’

At the outset of “Volta,” the Cirque du Soleil show now under the big top in San Francisco, a lively…

3 hours ago

Family members launch GoFundMe for Chinatown woman killed in fatal collision

Family members of a woman killed while crossing the street in San Francisco’s Chinatown earlier this month have launched a…

4 hours ago

San Francisco Dons men’s basketball postpones clash with Arizona State

Friday's University of San Francisco men's basketball game against Arizona State, slated for a 6:00 p.m. tip, has been postponed due…

4 hours ago

SF Preps: San Francisco Section postpones semifinal football games to Saturday due to air quality

The San Francisco Section has officially postponed its two semifinal football games yet again. After having already moved the games…

7 hours ago

Golden State Warriors drop fourth loss of the year as Draymond Green returns

By C.J. Peterson Special to S.F. Examiner Pushing the ball down court on a fast break opportunity in the first…

15 hours ago

The number of missing people in Butte County fire jumps dramatically to 631

The death toll from the devastating Camp fire in Northern California jumped to 63 on Thursday as search crews recovered…

17 hours ago