Categories: Arts Movies and TV

‘Eighth Grade’ is remarkably nonjudgmental, intuitive

Surely one of the year’s most notable writing and directing debuts, Bo Burnham’s “Eighth Grade” gets as close to the heart, mind and soul of a young person as a movie can.

Some films follow thrilling adventures of lucky young people; others are about sad, cruel events that befall unlucky kids. Viewers witness from an outside place, cheering along or shaking heads in grim realization.

Pete Docter’s “Inside Out” brilliantly imagined the inner workings of a young girl’s brain, and now “Eighth Grade” does something close to that without animation. It feels wonderfully real, mixed with pain, joy, uncertainty and love.

Its eighth grade hero is Kayla (Elsie Fisher, voice of Agnes in the “Despicable Me” movies); “hero” is an apt term for anyone trying as hard as she does.

With long, stringy-blond hair, acne-blotched face and big eyes, Kayla first appears making a YouTube video. (Burnham arrived on the scene via his own successful YouTube channel.)

In her unerringly natural, unsure, searching way of speaking, peppered with “um” and “like,” she tries to give advice to those watching (not many), signing off with what she thinks is a cute catchphrase (“Gucci!!”).

It’s the final stretch of the school year. At school, where she is voted “quietest,” she has no friends, but she crushes on Aiden (Luke Prael), voted “nicest eyes.” He’s one of those cool kids who seems to have everything together. She works up the courage to speak to him during a school shooter drill — this is a thing now — but the encounter goes shockingly sideways.

In the movie’s centerpiece, Kayla is given a proxy invitation to the birthday party of Kennedy (Catherine Oliviere), the most popular girl in school.

Burnham handles the scene masterfully. Kayla is rigid and terrified in a lumpy, green one-piece bathing suit, while everyone else at the party is having a good time; a traveling shot and series of staccato cuts turn Kayla’s first brave steps toward the pool into the stuff of stomach-clenching nightmare.

Kayla’s father (Josh Hamilton) — no mother is in sight — loves Kayla, constantly attempting to talk to her, but she pushes him away. He’s equally baffled and sheepish around her mood swings. In one powerful scene, she wonders if she makes him sad. His response is magical.

The movie takes a turn when Kayla spends a day at high school, assigned to shadow Olivia (Emily Robinson); they hit it off, and Olivia invites Kayla to the mall. But an encounter with one of Olivia’s male friends reminds us just how scary this world of being 13 can be.

Burnham never lets the material become shocking or heavy; he’s not speaking to adults about the surprising realities of children. He demonstrates understanding and sympathy for his heroine, and has a natural filmmaker’s command of light, rhythm, space and music.

Not surprisingly, “Eighth Grade” has technology and social media as a major theme; it’s exceedingly clever how it frequently juxtaposes the way things look with the way things are.

Early on, Kayla cracks her phone, but she continues to use it, sending hopeful texts and happy pictures through a unsightly hairline fracture. There’s an attempt to make everything seem peachy-keen, sometimes with little animal-ear filters, but life, especially at her age, is more about uncertainty.

Indeed, the biggest conflict in “Eighth Grade,” the scariest antagonist, is us, being too hard on ourselves. The miracle of Burnham’s film is that it understands, and forgives.

Eighth Grade
Three and a half stars
Starring: Elsie Fisher, Josh Hamilton, Emily Robinson, Luke Prael
Written and directed by: Bo Burnham
Rated R
Running time: 1 hour, 34 minutes

Jeffrey M. Anderson
Published by
Jeffrey M. Anderson

Recent Posts

SF Opera sets holiday mood with gratifying ‘It’s a Wonderful Life’

San Francisco Opera’s revised production of Jake Heggie’s opera “It’s a Wonderful Life” in its West Coast premiere is a…

2 hours ago

San Francisco 49ers sign linebacker James Onwualu to practice squad

The San Francisco 49ers have added linebacker James Onwualu to their practice squad, the team announced on Monday, its first…

2 hours ago

Elderly man sweeping SF parking lot robbed of watch at gunpoint

An elderly man was robbed of his watch in a violent armed robbery on Saturday morning while sweeping a parking…

2 hours ago

Family says video contradicts sheriff’s office story in Millbrae Taser death

The sister of an unarmed man who died after an Oct. 3 altercation with San Mateo County sheriff's deputies in…

3 hours ago

What I am grateful for on this Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving is a few days away, and soon we will gather with friends and family to eat and give thanks.…

11 hours ago

Residents face eviction after federal lawsuit shuts down state’s largest sober living provider

More than 250 residents of California’s largest sober living provider could face evictions on Monday, after a trustee who has…

12 hours ago