Categories: Arts Movies and TV

‘On Chesil Beach’ should be heartbreaking, but isn’t

A disastrous wedding night anchors “On Chesil Beach,” a flashback-filled British drama about two young newlyweds torn apart by a fear of sexual intimacy.

Featuring exceptional lead performances, the movie (opening Friday at the Embarcadero) might have been a gem for grown-ups seeking alternatives to Marvel. But its approach to the protagonists’ anxieties weakens essential emotional impact.

Based on the novella by Ian McEwan, who also wrote the screenplay, and directed by first-time filmmaker Dominic Cooke, the movie is a love story, a repressed-times period drama and an indictment of rigid social expectations.

The setting is pre-Beatles England, in 1962, before the Swinging Sixties and the generation gap changed how young people tackled the world.

Recent college grads Florence (Saoirse Ronan) and Edward (Billy Howle) come from different backgrounds — she’s from a well-off family; his father is a schoolmaster — but they are in love and enthusiastic about the future. She is a violinist with a string quartet. He wants to write history books.

We meet the pair as they walk and talk on the titular Dorset beach right after their wedding. Their tone sounds blissful, but that changes shortly, when, at a beachside inn, the two innocents nervously struggle to consummate their marriage.

Unease occurs during a hotel-room dinner, served by two waiters who won’t budge from the tableside. The tension increases with the awareness of the nearby bed, and what it signifies.

What initially plays as nervous comedy — a stuck zipper, overall klutziness, complete inexperience (picture a blend of “A Touch of Class” and Sofia Coppola’s “Marie Antoinette”) — turns into horror when Florence, freaked out by certain specifics, bolts from the bed. On the beach, a shattering argument takes place.

Flashbacks attempt to reveal why Florence dreads intimacy and why Edward has anger issues. We see family woes: Florence’s parents (Emily Watson, Samuel West) are classist and overbearing; Edward’s artist mother (Anne-Marie Duff), due to a train-related accident, has debilitating brain damage.

Ronan, excellent as always, and Howle, an exciting emerging talent, give complex performances, convincingly portraying people who are in love, and products of their time, in 1962.

Cooke and the actors make the wedding-night anxiety palpable. The courtship flashbacks contain engaging moments. Cooke also addresses the British obsession with class.

But too often, the movie’s focus and storytelling methods prove problematic. By treating Florence’s fear of sex as a mystery and using frequent flashbacks to examine it, the film leaves viewers feeling yanked around and teased. A hint that something unsavory occurring in Florence’s family demands more concrete treatment.

Flash-forward sequences are maudlin, worsened by old-age makeup.

Such material may jerk some tears, but it’s not enough. With the talent involved, “On Chesil Beach” could have been a genuine heartbreaker.


On Chesil Beach
Two and a half stars
Starring: Saoirse Ronan, Billy Howle, Anne-Marie Duff, Emily Watson
Written by: Ian McEwan
Directed by: Dominic Cooke
Rated R
Running time: 1 hour, 50 minutes

Anita Katz
Published by
Anita Katz

Recent Posts

BART equipment failure fills Civic Center Station with smoke

Smoke from an equipment failure on a BART track prompted transit officials to temporarily close Civic Center Station on Saturday…

6 mins ago

RV life

David Samples lived in a rundown 1971 Chinook RV in the Bayview District for about six months before he sought…

9 hours ago

Oakland Athletics could clinch playoff berth at home as magic number drops to one

OAKLAND -- The Tampa Bay Rays had just fallen behind 3-1 to the Toronto Blue Jays, and in the Oakland…

9 hours ago

Questions remain as Treasurer’s Public Bank Task Force comes to a close

Seven months after convening the Municipal Public Bank Task Force and after, presumably, seven months of research, public bank advocates…

9 hours ago

Who’s in charge at Lake Merced?

Lake Merced is a recreational and natural wonder in the southwest corner of San Francisco. Rowers, dragon boat racers, golfers,…

9 hours ago

Introducing the softest politicians in the Bay this week

While Republicans set a low bar for corruption and incompetence, I don’t know how California can hope to win at…

9 hours ago