Bill to abolish money bail in California reaches governor’s desk

Gov. Jerry Brown will decide whether to abolish money bail in California after the state Senate on Tuesday sent him a sweeping overhaul of California’s pretrial detention system.

Senate Bill 10 would eliminate bail, replacing it with “risk assessments” of individuals and nonmonetary conditions of release. Advocates contend that too many Californians remain stuck in custody because they cannot afford to bail out, effectively creating unequal justice based on wealth.

Brown expressed his support for the effort last year when the authors pulled an earlier version of the measure, which fell short in the Legislature, to negotiate with the governor and Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye. He would not commit to signing SB 10 last week as they unveiled the revised proposal that emerged from those discussions.

The Senate passed the measure largely along party lines, 26-12, with nearly all Democrats and one Republican in support. Several called the current criminal justice system unconstitutional, biased and a failure.

“We start off our session every day pledging allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic, for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all,” Sen. Hannah-Beth Jackson, D-Santa Barbara, said. “Not for the rich. Not for those who can’t afford bail. But for all.”

Republicans warned the measure would endanger public safety and that lawmakers rushed the final language through the legislative process without public hearings.

“This is not a get out of jail free card. This is a stay out of jail card,” Sen. Jim Nielsen, R-Gerber, said. “There is no doubt that many of these tens of thousands of individuals have indeed committed a crime, victimized the constituents we represent. Think about them.”

The Senate vote followed just five days after backers of SB 10 released the compromise legislation. Proponents moved quickly to pass the measure as former allies announced their objections to the new plan and urged lawmakers to defeat it. Despite complaints about the rushed timeline, the Assembly narrowly passed the bill on Monday.

Several organizations that sponsored the original version of the measure, including the American Civil Liberties Union of California, raised concerns that SB 10 would unjustly expand the number of suspects jailed while awaiting trial. They pointed to a provision in the bill expanding the process for “preventive detention,” giving judges more discretion to block a defendant’s release if they believe there are no conditions that would ensure public safety or their return to court.

-By Alexei Koseff and Taryn Luna, The Sacramento Bee

Tribune News Service
Published by
Tribune News Service

Recent Posts

1 dead, 1 arrested in SoMa hit and run

A 65-year-old man was struck and killed by a vehicle in a hit-and-run in San Francisco's South of Market neighborhood…

1 hour ago

If you want to address climate change, clean up the air

Like climate change itself, recent environmental news from throughout the country can feel overwhelming and scary. As leaders from around…

10 hours ago

Transportation justice requires housing justice, and vice versa

Why should transportation advocates support ballot measures put forth by housing activists? And why should housing activists defend a gas…

10 hours ago

Report finds community benefit districts linked to displacement, harassment

An advocacy group is calling on The City to block business improvement districts from using tax dollars to address quality…

10 hours ago

Homes not cars on Divisadero

People in the Divisadero neighborhood are trying to stop new housing by calling for fees (taxes) which would make projects…

10 hours ago

Sept. 19-20: Greta Van Fleet, Dawn Wall, Lessons from China, Oktoberfest, Peter Phillips, P.J. O’Rourke, Liz Phair, Sondheim Tonight!, Prida Project, Miguel, Eagles, J. Balvin, Boz Scaggs

WEDNESDAY, SEPT. 19 Greta Van Fleet: The young Kiszka brothers (Jake, Josh and Sam) and their friend drummer Danny Wagner,…

11 hours ago